|
Originally posted by : AASHA |
 |
Dear mr. vijay it is not necessary to attend coaching classes . self study also is enought if one DO study seriously, and secondaly on this platform when we are pursuing a very dynamic professional degree how we can blame anyone [coaching classes] for our wrong decisions.
When we are pursuing for such a valuable degree we must be capable enough to understand what is wrong and what is right.
No one can convince CA students [any coaching class] like small kids . If we are accepting any classes AS GOOD we must have feeling of better understanding .
what you are talking is " WE BELEIVED BUT WE FAILED"
so try to be self dependent than depending on others.
Our professional ethics does not allow us to criticise anyone.
" IT IS ALWAYS BETTER TO CHANGE OURSELF THAN TO OTHERS" |
 |
Hold on dear, so many questions and presumptions...
First thanks for presenting other side of views, I hope you(or others who read) will take my comments as they are without any personal attacks
Now can I ask something, have you ever seen atleast one individual who says 'I don't fit this course' with a dullness in his/her eyes? I never saw it 5 years back when i joined as a CPT student but now when i meet my juniors, i see many. Have you ever seen a mob, yes it was a mob really which just joined CA because they saw it in ad that CA will get them job for sure? i saw 100's of them (one of these institutes had a hostel near my home AND I spoke to them) They don't like the subject nor do even know meaning of 'Chartered' or what society expects from them.
Now coming to what you said, yes I agree self-study is sufficient. Infact for final I did it myself. Not all are capable of it, sply when in small town with no idea of what it is like to be in a corporate world.
Next ‘pursuing a very dynamic professional degree’, the profession itself is in harm here, then how can we just close our eyes and be in false sense of security saying ‘We are in a prestigious profession’ There will be no professionalism left except in idealists. I don’t want to go further and make myself an example for lack of professional behaviour.
Then I don’t know where you are from or what state but in the place I am, it’s just market sentiment which leads people to study, earlier it was engineering and now CA and that number is in thousands and showing trends to reach lakhs, just in a small town. Just like economics says ‘Advertisement is a way to increase demand’ The number of students joining CA is not driven by knowledge regarding course or passion it’s pure sentiment, just like in share market how a small and new investor behaves, goes with the tide. May be we should start a ‘CA potential student education and protection fund’ to promote awareness.
Try to be self-dependent, easier said than done. This is just like a presumption in M.M. model, info is freely available to all and all are knowledgeable investors. Is that true? I don’t know I am not a CA as yet.
I changed myself and I am accepting whatever comes my way is my responsibility but sorry, I feel responsible in the same way to stop the image of CA taking a beating in ordinary public. It should not be seen as same as others, a job provider. It just does not go with me.
CAclubindia
