26 November 2016
Hello sir,
is it good to study audit from practice manual of icai.
I heard from many that the practice manual is not arranged properly and it is difficult to study from there.
26 November 2016
Not agree with you. understanding is important but at the same time following a good book is also very important.
opportunity cost of not following a good book is very high.
28 November 2016
U can take help of Surbhi Bansal. One thing keep in mind Mr. Rajdeep, u can't contradict with an expert answer, if u are asking for help. If u knows everything, then why are u asking? It only depends on candidate that which way, he/she understand the concept. In exam u are never asked to give reference of the book from where u have studied. Many are taking tution classes, then why are u going for books??We can also say, BOOK IS IMPORTANT, BUT AT THE SAME TIME FOLLOWING A GOOD TUTION CLASSES IS VERY IMPORTANT(UR SO CALLED OPPORTUNITY COST).
28 November 2016
Dear sir, my point was suppose there is a book which doesn't cover the entire syllabus, then how would you come to know if one our more important point is missing?? and there are lots of book like this.
I am not doing formality here by agreeing with an expert..
29 November 2016
Authors will always say to buy their books, to increase their revenue. There are cases in ICAI examinations in past, when 40-50% of the questions were asked out of syllabus. At that time no one can help u. And I had suggested u the name of the Author from which u can take help. Outside books are only to increase ur base regarding the topic. They never told anything out from ICAI syllabus.
29 November 2016
Being a CA student, Atleast analysis of Questions paper is a very fundamental thing. If you call me expert for this only, salute to you.
29 November 2016
U r acting like an expert. U contradict reply of a senior expert Mr. Vinod. U r asking to solve ur problem and also at the same time, acting arrogant. What to do with u? U know everything, so we are bound to accept u expert. Regarding analysis of questions, its always a duty of a student to do that. Well, way to go dear.................. And thanks for the salute. Thats an appreciation for me. :)
29 November 2016
Respected sir, please do not take this in your ego. the things I told here are correct, please try to think from my fence also considering yourself as a student.
29 November 2016
Not taking on ego I m still replying, otherwise U may be restricted to login to this very site. Not taking on ego I suggested u the name of the book u may refer for the subject. Being a student in past and from my experience of checking the answer scripts of students(IPC & Finals & CS too) I suggested u the past pattern of the questions in examination. So I m never ever taking anything on my ego. We have other works also, but we are devoting our precious time to answer to ur queries. All the best for ur future....................
CAclubindia
