Tax implication of sale of tdr- ltcg/ business income/ os

S S Dahale ( Agri and business) (439 Points)

13 May 2017  

  Tax implication case is  , Mr A ., who is not in to REAL ESTATE  bought  NON agri res.land in 1996 @ Rs12 per sqmtr , in Muncipal Limits  Maharashtra, he incurred expenses on its development @ Rs170 per SqMtr in  year2001, also  got approval from competent authorities in 2003,
 sold some part of it  till 2007, paid LTCG on it  / bought LTCG bonds as per sec.54.

  provision of TDR ( against affected DP roads)came to be sanctioned in 2008 at Munc .Corporation,
 accordingly Mr A  applied for  Grant of TDR s for  affected  portion around 2300 Sq.Mtr  in 2012. of portion 925and 1375 sq.mtr,

as directed by authorities , being necessary also made expense as directed by authorities  for affected portion in 2015 at Rs300 per Sq.mtr

on affected area of 925 Sq.Mtr. as per  final apparel of area 925 Sq mtr of it of july 2015 , Mr.A relinquished  only 925 favoring municipal corporation in  Jan 2016

  for the same Mr.A was allotted TDR certificate of 2030 SqMtr in  may 2017.

 Now Mr A ( being owner) am selling  TDR of 175 sq Mtr for Rs.5 lacs in May 2017
  His  dilemma is  )(i)whether  this INCOME (as per proceeds)should  be treated as business income or LTCG or Income from other sources

 (ii)if, that income to be treated as  LTCG
 then  what will be basic index  for cost  of acquisition  as 305 of year 1996. OR  or 426 of year 2001 (as mentioned in recent finance bill)
 can  Mr.A get benefit of indexed expenses incurred  for its development and betterment by Mr.A  in 2001 @ Rs170 Sq.Mtr and Rs.300 in year 2015.