I am referring Bangar for IDT.But it contains less solved practical problems on customs & excise.Plz suggest me a book for IDT which contains more solved problems on IDT?
swapnil dabke (senior executive) (320 Points)
22 November 2010I am referring Bangar for IDT.But it contains less solved practical problems on customs & excise.Plz suggest me a book for IDT which contains more solved problems on IDT?
tejinder
(article)
(30 Points)
Replied 22 November 2010
hi swapnil dabke,
i have referred this book .
major drawback of this book is
> u cannot revise from this book in exams time
> after giving case law no conclusion is given
> in case law unnecessary detail is given & most of the cases are not concluded in the light of relevant provision
>no summary of topics are given
>in this book for full understanding of provisions u have also need to read bare act portion
so my advice don't fully depend on this book for exams
Jithin
(Learner)
(1057 Points)
Replied 23 November 2010
Dear Tejinder, thank u so much for pointing out the defects of that buk. I wud be grateful if u could similarly specify the good things of that buk. Also tell me whether u use another book. If u are referring to any other buk, could u please specify the advantages as well as disadvantages of that buk(just the way u stated the drawbacks of Bangar). Waiting for ur reply.
@ Swapnil
Thanks a lot for posting this query.
CA AYUSH AGRAWAL
(Kolkata-Pune-Mumbai)
(26986 Points)
Replied 23 November 2010
ajay jain is also good
Gunjan Jain
(CA)
(127 Points)
Replied 23 November 2010
Ajay Jain book is not available in the market.
In Law point kolkata, they told me ajay book will not publish from this time.
Now I m confuse.
CA.Madhusudan B.P.
(Chartered Accountant)
(1157 Points)
Replied 23 November 2010
To all,
why cant you go for VSDatey or Saravana prasat & G Shekar very good from CA final exam point of view.
Alternatively you can you use the institute compliation for your practical question....
Jithin
(Learner)
(1057 Points)
Replied 23 November 2010
| Originally posted by : CA.Madhusudan B.P. | ||
 |
To all, why cant you go for VSDatey or Saravana prasat & G Shekar very good from CA final exam point of view. Alternatively you can you use the institute compliation for your practical question.... |
 |
Dear Sir, I have bought VS Datey & it seems to be a nice book(have just read 1 chapter from excise). But it does not have many problems..Also many people are saying it is a very vast book dealing with many issues irrelevant for the exams. For me time is at premium since I am doing self study & my preparation upto now is not very great.
In my opinion, Paduka is not at all suitable for self study. It does not help u in understanding the topic. It can be used for only solving problems. As regards compilation, it is not available for indirect tax.
Please suggest any book:
1)which gives conceptual knowledge & is not purely exam oriented(like Paduka)
2)which is not very vast(since time is a factor)
3)which contains a reasonable number of problems.
I want a book similar to T.N.Manoharan's direct tax book(which explains concepts well but is not at all lengthy)
chandra
(student)
(528 Points)
Replied 23 November 2010
Suggest you use institute's study material. Subject is well explained.
You can download soft copy from Institute's web side Students->BOS Study Portal->Final->Study Material
New edition for May/Nov 2011 exams will be available by 1st week of March 2011.
Base your studies on Study material Supplement with V S Datey's book
Yashwanth Jain
(Ca )
(82 Points)
Replied 23 November 2010
You can try with Dipak Gupta notes which explains the topics in a simple language and also has got relevant practical case studies and problems.
Ranotosh Podder
(ca student)
(394 Points)
Replied 23 November 2010
Deepak gupta's book is also not available all over India.Ajay jain' book is out of market.
I think there is a crisis of student friendly book in IDT.
Nisha
(Chartered Accountant)
(47 Points)
Replied 25 November 2010
There is no crisis for good books, all u need to do is change ur mindset..
Bangar one of the best book for ca final idt... and if u want to solve more practical questions than can refer to Insti publication (i.e. Complier)
Further in case one wants to have deep understanding of excise n customs than refer V.S., Datey book.
But I would suggest stick to one book only n dat is bangar....
Don't run here n there for every notes or books, one gud book is enough for preparation...
CS Ankur Srivastava
(Company Secretary & Compliance Officer)
(17848 Points)
Replied 25 November 2010
Dont be confused... Take one book. The main object is to clear your concept and make your base strong.Once your concept is clear any type of question, you can solve ealily.
All the Best.
Ranganath
(Student)
(37 Points)
Replied 25 November 2010
If you need Conceptual clarity : DIPPAK GUPTA or NS GOVINDAN or VS DATEY
If you need for concepts as well exam orientation: YOGENDRA BHANGAR and PADUKA Publications
If you have conceptual clarity and worked on few problems in IDT that would be sufficient...Take any ONE BOOK and stick to it. If Possible make your own notes for revision BEFORE EXAMINATION...Because You need to Brush up each and every topic before exam...NO CHOICE for STUDY though INSTITUTE will give CHOICE...
I heard you can order Dippak Gupta books from Pooja Law House...Try alternative means to buy books
ALL THE VERY BEST
RANGANATH
Priyanka Agarwal
(CA FINAL)
(55 Points)
Replied 04 February 2011
Pls sugest which book for idt,only for practical practice.is there is measure amendments for may 11 term.i followed jayesh gupta mat for idt for nov 10 exam.is reqired to change?already purchased practice manual.
"Live Course on Python for Financial Analysis: Unlocking Efficiency in Accounting and Finance"
CAclubindia
