Ca final law ppr

Page no : 2

Binidh (CFA) (61 Points)
Replied 01 June 2014

No extra marks are given for section but marks are desucted for quoting wrong section ...

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

gaurav (ca) (30 Points)
Replied 01 June 2014

IS QUESTION 5A out of course. As this qustion was from the topic of Winding Up which was out of course

kishore choudhury (article asst.) (114 Points)
Replied 01 June 2014

Buddy no worries. Quoting section without a appropriate content won't fetch you marks. The content of the sections is important in your answer sheet. Even I fetched 70 marks without giving reference to a single section number. All the best....no worries make yourself ready for the next exam.

anil bhandari (chartered accountant) (23 Points)
Replied 01 June 2014

Even without section and case laws u will score more than 75 percent marks

CA Twinkle (Chartered Accountant) (65 Points)
Replied 01 June 2014

Starting for Costing n qt is the best.. We all will try to get nice marks in further 4 papers ... :)

Upgrade to CAclubindia Pro. Subscribe Now!

Rohit (article assistant) (21 Points)
Replied 01 June 2014

Papr ws not easy. Need to have knowledge of minute provisons eith gr8 detail.

Minakshi (non working) (57 Points)
Replied 01 June 2014

Same here, paper was different this time. No conviction in answers. ICAI now wants us to be CORPORATE Lawyers.

Robin (AUDITOR) (854 Points)
Replied 01 June 2014

Am expecting to score above 70 in today's Final Law paper..

My answer sheet glimpses here

Q 1 (a) Sec 233A Only CG can appoint special Auditor

(d) Complaint to SAT

Q 3 (a) Within 7 days, FORM 23AA, ROC filing and Maintain for 8 years if less period existence of the company then such shorter period

(b) Regulation 92 - 95 of SEBI follow...

Q 4 (a) priro approval of CG required sec - 295 and director VACATE sec- 283

(b) section 388B - E and Section 408 ofcourse go to section 397

Q 5 (a) No sustainance of shareholder objection refer section 433

(b) Section 36 of banking act...winding up the bank or amalgamate in public interest etc etc..

Q 6. (a) (ii) Constitution, place of business , authorised person to receive notice and said documents to be submitted to New Delhi ROC office.and state in which place of business

(b) section 260Additional Director or Casual Vacancy 262 appoint

Q. 7 (b) Predatory pricing means selling at a price below the cost of production so No abuse of dominant position

(c)section 17 not less than 20% transfer to Reserve Fund..yess violated

(e) Rs. 500000 penalty Imrisonment 3 years to 7 years and extend to 10 years if para 2 of part A violated.

The above answers are perfect

Aarsh (student) (31 Points)
Replied 01 June 2014

Dear Kartik, the main focus is on your ability to apply provisions in practical situations...you should be able to eleborate the provisions in full n corelate it with the situation.. quoting sections will definately show your clear knowledge... it adds to the value of your answer n you will get better marks... however there is not much harm if you cant quote the exact section...icai understands that few people may not be able remember any section so it gives good marks even if u cant quote the section.. all the best for coming exams

gaurav (ca) (30 Points)
Replied 01 June 2014

Dear robin - 6(b) - Its a deadlock. Best possible remidies - 1) One director can acquire other direCtor stake at fair market price 2) Winding up.of company