4 Lac Members


Discussion > Income Tax > Others > Speculation Loss can be set off against Delivery Based Profi Unanswered Threads    Post New Topic

Pages : 1




There are 2 Replies to this message



MitaBhat
Manager
[ Scorecard : 404]
Posted On 08 March 2010 at 11:02 Report Abuse

Report Abuse / Feedback


Name
Email
Subject
Message

Verify Verify Code 
  

Note : The above form can be used to intimate the moderators regarding abuse of the platform.


 

Speculation Loss can be set off against Delivery Based Profits

The assessee earned a profit on sale of shares held as stock-in-trade. This profit was offered as profit from a ’speculation business’ and was set off against a ’speculation loss’ brought forward from an earlier assessment year. The AO took the view that the profit from sale of shares was not from a ’speculation business’ on the ground that the assessee had settled its transaction of sale and purchase of shares through physical delivery.

On appeal by the Revenue, HELD affirming the Tribunal’s order:

Source >>> www.forum4finance.com


Share This


llllVICTORllll
PCC-Article
[ Scorecard : 250]
Posted On 08 March 2010 at 12:30

Ok, now my Doubt is, what if assessee is not a company, then does all trading is shares, irrespective of delivery or non delivery be treated as speculation business?



Priya
Articled Clerk
[ Scorecard : 302]
Posted On 08 March 2010 at 21:27

Speculative transactions In case of a company, if part of its business consists of dealing in shares then all types of transactions, whether delivery based or non-delivery based, will be treated as speculative transactions.


 





Related Files


 


Previous Thread Next Thread


Related Threads


 

Post your reply for Speculation Loss can be set off against Delivery Based Profi



Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to login


Not a member yet ?? Click here to signup

Message