MBA from well known established b schools are far better. what use of knowledge when it doesn't pay. If u wanna be professor in some dingy govt college then study CA for knowledge; lick all the crumbs that the principal throws towards the article, bear his abuses in front of clients even if that is maa ben ki gaali,clear his electrivity bills;  bring chai from kitli, etc.

The  industry shows the proof which one is alarming. There wasn't even an iota of doubt about MBA from top 20 schools being far ahead of CA. But abb sharm ki baat yeh hain ki now MBA from chunubunu instt also are gaining starting salary from their students. At least, they offer no exploitation in the hands of teachers like in CA our sources of learning ie Principal usually exploit articles for 1000pm(they have bought us yaar).

MBA schools don't change exam syllabus 2 weeks before exam.

Better stipend during internship. abb toh chunu bunu mba school se bhi starting salary 4-5 lac hoti hain. And our ICAI says fresh CA passout gets average 6 lacs pa. I have seen fresh CA passout getting no job(mind u they were not dummy); or some being forced to work under 2 lacs pa.

If one is doing CA from big4 or multi-exposure waley firm and getting cleared in 2 attempt at most then they will have sort of comparison with MBA.

If a heap of bones contains 1-2 diamond pieces; some pearls and some rubies; the entire HEAP CAN'T BE CONSIDERED A TREASURE.

Abhi CA ki aaur kachra karrdiya hain. Do CA from ACCA, ya icaew,australian CPA and then take membership of ICAI.IF all these openings were there when i joined CPT; muje kutte ne nai kaata hai ki aise dimag ki dahi bananey wala scheme main enroll karta. Kabhi bhi rule change karr detey hain. Hadd karte hain yaar.Nokarr banakey rakhtey hain aur boltey hain yeh guru-shishya parampara hain. Silly men.We need Obama like visionist to run ICAI

Total thanks : 2 times

 DHO DIYA YAR

Total thanks : 1 times

what dho diya mean?

But i agree with u, sushant. ICAI only brags about its degree and try to copy mba by introducing MBS. But icai shouldn't forget that a seller just by introducing a product doesn't become successful, he has to insure that the product satisfies the consumer.

Here, the basic product of icai is faulty. ICAI doesn't even respond to the feedback of students about the CA course.

PERFECT ANSWERS TO INSTITUTES KARTUTIEN !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

SPECIALLY FOR SUSHANT'S PERFECT COMMENT FOR GURU SHISYA PURAMPRA AND ABOVE SAID POLICIES OF ICAI.    

SUSHANT...YOU ARE ABSOLUTELY RIGHT !!!

COMPLETELY AGREE WITH YOU....THERE HAS TO BE A WAY TO BRING THIS IN THE PUBLIC.

THROUGH SOME NEWS CHANNEL PERHAPS. 

THESE PEOPLE PLAY GAMES WITH OUR LIVES !!AND THEY HAVE CROSSED ALL THE LIMITS..... IT IS SIMPLE NOT RIGHT !!

I am really sorry when i have to say this; but this is heartbreakinlgy true. ICAI's course is popular as it has got the monopoly protection from the Central government. If we evaluate the course content, administration of student's welfare in academics, job viability,so called practical exposure(selling us like pimps); taking away the equation of monopoly of CAs from icai to conduct audit; then it will as " good" as other bogus accounting training centres like ICFAI,CIA, NIFA, etc.

On the other hand, has the government banned schools to teach MBA? Even then the value of IIM,FMS,SPKM,NM, etc hasn't dimisnished.LAcs of students give exams to be in them.

That is the case, my Lord.

The case is as good as closed for UPA

and what about the dhongg of cheap course. cheap my foot. We get 1000pm and icai says that will support our learning. What about our fooding, lodging,stationery, transport, medicines. We spend 70000 approx for coahing institute.The love for money alone prompted icai to launch their own coaching classes and target pvt. coaching centres. Self study to sirf einstein karr saktaa hain; coz icai modules are bulky, not marks oriented,outdated, and it sucks.

So how is it a cheap course. Plus, we have to see the risk-return relationship.icai just tries to put the wool over our eyes

Given below is the table showing certain figures of the Campus Placement Program of ICAI.

The numbers speak by themselves so I need not mention my interpretation.

Source : http://www.placements-icai.org/

Is there still any doubt on the fact that ICAI has lost brand value and all the claims made by it regarding impact of recession on CAs being very less are false?

 Comparing two different professions?

Each has different role to play and it depends ypon Company to Company