Please Wait ..

Sign-in to your account


Username:
Password:

Remember Me

Forgot your password?

Sign-up now



Join CAclubindia.com and Share your Knowledge. Registered members get a chance to interact at Forum, Ask Query, Comment etc.


Discussion > Income Tax > Tax queries >

Intimation u/s 143(1) - urgent please can u help

    Post New Topic
Pages : 1 2





Learning Tax

[ Scorecard : 129]
Posted On 04 November 2011 at 17:42 Report Abuse

Dear all, Please can you help me I have some confusions?

Assessee: Male: Senior Citizen. A.Y: 2008-2009

Due date of Return: 31-07-2008

Date of Filling Return: 30-07-2009

 

As per Intimation u/s 143(1)

Net Income: 5,90,800/-

TDS: NIL

SAT: Rs. 1,07,300/-

Tax.: Rs. 1,13,238/-

E.Cess: Rs. 3,397/-

u/s 234A: Rs. 13,992/-

u/s 234B: Rs. 26,990/-

u/s 234C: Rs. 4,316/-

Total Int Due: Rs. 45,298/-

Total Int & Tax due: Rs. 1,61,933/-

Less: Prepaid Taxes: Rs. 1,07,300/-

Balance Tax Payable: Rs. 54,633/-

 

Calculation as per our Filled Return:

Net Income: Rs. 5,90,800

Tax.: Rs. 1,13,240

E.Cess: Rs. 3,397

Total Taxes payable: Rs. 1,16,637/-

TDS: Rs. 9,369/-

SAT paid on Dt: 20-07-2009: Rs. 1,07,300/-

Total Taxes paid: Rs. 1,16,669/-

No Interest u/s 234A, 234B, 234C has been paid.

 

 

The Intimation u/s 143(1) is generated on Dt. 12-1-2011., but recd by ordinary post on Dt.2-11-2011., TDS deducted ignored by the ITO. I find that the calculation made by ITO is wrong.

My questions are:

  1. Can you help me with, what should be the right calculation?
  2. No Challan accompanied with the said intimation, issued by the I.T.O?
  3. Why is the intimation recd. So late after 10 months the post stamp is also of Dt. 1-11-2011?
  4. What should be done in this matter?

 

Please can you help me solve these confusions! Thanks!

 

 


Online classes for CA CS CMA



U S Sharma
glidor@gmail.com

[ Scorecard : 19381]
Posted On 04 November 2011 at 20:32

check tax credit in 26AS and file rectification u/s 154



Total thanks : 1 times




Snehal
Learning Tax

[ Scorecard : 129]
Posted On 05 November 2011 at 15:01

            Sir, Thanks for your prompt reply. We have already checked the Tax Credit, No details of either TDS or Sat is mentioned in Tax Credit in Form 26AS for A.Y 2008-2009 (However SAT of Rs. 1,07,300 is wrongly mentioned in 26AS as SAT for A.Y 2009-2010, I wonder when Form 26S is showing SAT as NIL for 2008-2008 then how have the ITO has correctly accounted Sat & why has he not accounted the TDS).

But we have the all the TDS Certificates. TDS deducted is on Bank Interest. I will go for rectification u/s 154, but am confused and unable to calculate the exact figure of Balance Tax & Interest to be paid. For representing the case, I should atleast know the said figure.

Can you please help reply my questions?
  1. Can you help me with, what should be the right calculation?
  2. No Challan accompanied with the said intimation, issued by the I.T.O?
  3. Why is the intimation recd. So late after 10 months the post stamp is also of Dt. 1-11-2011?
  4. What should be done in this matter?
 



MANIK KUMAR
CA FINAL STUDENT & ARTICLE AT R BANSAL & CO

[ Scorecard : 698]
Posted On 10 November 2011 at 08:14

YOU HAVE TO PAY 234A, 234B,234C, INTERST

 



Total thanks : 1 times



U S Sharma
glidor@gmail.com

[ Scorecard : 19381]
Posted On 10 November 2011 at 09:01

1) your return was filed more than one year of delay

2) recheck 26AS, and find tax credits,(TDS), unless it appears in 26AS, ITO can not allow the TDS credit., if the same is not reflected in your 26AS, you have to chase deductor , as they might have not filed the return properly.



Total thanks : 1 times



Snehal
Learning Tax

[ Scorecard : 129]
Posted On 10 November 2011 at 12:17

          U. S. Sharma Sir, Thanks once again, we rechecked the Form 26AS, But No details of either TDS or SAT is reflected in the Tax Credit in Form 26AS for A.Y 2008-2009. Yes the return & SAT payment was delayed as informed earlier as the assessee is a Senior Citizen (70+) and was sick and his source of income is mainly from Pension and Bank Interest. But he is dedicated to keep his I.T File clear and pay Income Tax & Help the Nation.

 

          As said earlier (SAT of Rs. 1,07,300 paid for A.Y 2008-2009 is wrongly mentioned in 26AS as SAT for A.Y 2009-2010, but the ITO has correctly accounted this Sat).

 

          We have the all the TDS Certificates. As said earlier TDS deducted is on F.D Bank Interest and chasing Nationalized Banks to rectify their TDS returns that too for F.Y 2007-2008., is nearly difficult, they will say that we have already issued you TDS Certificates.

 

Dear Manik the assessee is ready to pay the interest on Tax. But calculations thereof in this scenario is a bit confusing.

Can someone atleast help with the correct figures of Interest calculations u/s 234A, 234B & 234C. As per our filled ITR & Calculations taking into account the TDS & SAT.

 

Calculation as per our Filled Return:

A.Y 2008-2009: Assessee : Sr Ctz.

Net Taxable Income: Rs. 5,90,800/-

Tax.: Rs.1,13,240/-

E.Cess: Rs. 3,397/-

Total Taxes payable: Rs. 1,16,637/-

TDS: Rs. 9,369/-

SAT paid on Dt: 20-07-2009: Rs. 1,07,300/-.

Total Taxes paid: Rs. 1,16,669/-”

 

What would be the Interest payable u/s 234A, 234B & 234C?

The said intimation is recd late after 10 months the post stamp on envelope is also of Dt. 1-11-2011. What is the time limit for filling Application for Rectification u/s 154?

Please Help me out in the situation, an early reply is solicited!




Tanay Choksi
Student

[ Scorecard : 96]
Posted On 11 November 2011 at 12:01

Hi Shenal,

We are also facing some similar problems.

Firstly, Check counterfoil of challan to see which A.Y. is mentioned in it.  If it A.Y. 2008-09 and since you have filed return in 2009 possibly I feel that there must be data entry error by Bank or NSDL(A.Y. 2008-09 considered as F.Y. 2008-09). Go for Correction of SAT for which you must write to ITO.

As regards TDS, recheck Form 16A to see if PAN of Assessee is correctly mentioned. If it is  not correctly mentioned or in any other case go to the Deductor with print of Form 26AS and tell them that Tax deducted is not reflected online and they should file their(BANK OR DEDUCTOR) Corrected TDS Return after which TDS will be reflected in Form 26AS.

The assess will have to pay Interest U/s 234A, 234B, 234C but the same as calculated by ITO will be reduced once TDS deducted is reflected in Form 26AS

Also tell me sir whether you filed return physically or electronically(E-Return).  This is because of your query that when SAT is not reflected in 26AS & the same shown in A.Y. 2009-10, ITO has given credit for the same.

Answer: If you have filed return physically(in ITO Ward) the you might have accompanied Challan with Return. So ITO included it in his Computation. And as TDS is not reflected in 26AS, he didnt give you credit for same.

Regards,

Tanay Choksi

 




Snehal
Learning Tax

[ Scorecard : 129]
Posted On 24 November 2011 at 15:38

We have prepared an application for Rectification u/s 154

Please can anyone confirm if the same is in order?

Dear Sir,

        Please refer to the reference and subject cited hereinabove. With reference to the same I am to inform you that I have filed my Income Tax Returns for the A.Y --------------- in ITR-4 on Dt. --------------- Copy of acknowledgement of ITR-4 for the A.Y --------------- Dt. --------------- is enclosed herewith).

  1. I had made payment of Self Assessment Tax of Rs. 1,07,000/- for the said Assessment Year ------, in Bank.

 

  1. Further T.D.S of Rs. 9,369/- has been deducted by the Banks. (Copy of Form 16A – TDS Certificate is enclosed herewith for your kind reference.)

 

  1. In your Intimation u/s 143(1), though the SAT paid has been duly reflected, but the T.D.S is neither reflected not considered.

     Hence I am making this Application u/s 154, for Rectification of Mistake apparent and to bring to your kind Notice that T.D.S of Rs. 9,369/- has been deducted from my Income for Assessment Year----------. The details of the said T.D.S has also been duly mentioned in my returns filled vide ITR4. But the same has not been accounted in your aforesaid intimation for payment of Income Tax for the Assessment Year ----------.

 

        Thus I request you to consider the said T.D.S of Rs. 9,369/-. Further the Interest calculated u/s 234A, u/s 234B and 234C totaling to Rs. 45,298/- has to be revised taking into consideration the T.D.S of Rs. 9,369/-.

 

        Therefore I request you to rectify the said mistake apparent from the records & account the T.D.S of Rs. 9,369/-. and accordingly amend, revise & rectify the assessment and Intimation under section 143(1).

 

Please confirm if the said application is in order?

We have prepared an application for Rectification u/s 154

Please can anyone confirm if the same is in order?

Dear Sir,

        Please refer to the reference and subject cited hereinabove. With reference to the same I am to inform you that I have filed my Income Tax Returns for the A.Y --------------- in ITR-4 on Dt. --------------- Copy of acknowledgement of ITR-4 for the A.Y --------------- Dt. --------------- is enclosed herewith).

  1. I had made payment of Self Assessment Tax of Rs. 1,07,000/- for the said Assessment Year ------, in Bank.

 

  1. Further T.D.S of Rs. 9,369/- has been deducted by the Banks. (Copy of Form 16A – TDS Certificate is enclosed herewith for your kind reference.)

 

  1. In your Intimation u/s 143(1), though the SAT paid has been duly reflected, but the T.D.S is neither reflected not considered.

     Hence I am making this Application u/s 154, for Rectification of Mistake apparent and to bring to your kind Notice that T.D.S of Rs. 9,369/- has been deducted from my Income for Assessment Year----------. The details of the said T.D.S has also been duly mentioned in my returns filled vide ITR4. But the same has not been accounted in your aforesaid intimation for payment of Income Tax for the Assessment Year ----------.

 

        Thus I request you to consider the said T.D.S of Rs. 9,369/-. Further the Interest calculated u/s 234A, u/s 234B and 234C totaling to Rs. 45,298/- has to be revised taking into consideration the T.D.S of Rs. 9,369/-.

 

        Therefore I request you to rectify the said mistake apparent from the records & account the T.D.S of Rs. 9,369/-. and accordingly amend, revise & rectify the assessment and Intimation under section 143(1).

 

Please confirm if the said application is in order?




U S Sharma
glidor@gmail.com

[ Scorecard : 19381]
Posted On 24 November 2011 at 22:17

Put PAN no in the letter format

also try to make reconcillation of 26AS with your TDS form 16A, unless the TDS is reflected in 26AS, form 16A is useless paper for refund grant.




satish kumar voleti
A.C.A., (ICWAI)

[ Scorecard : 1661]
Posted On 25 November 2011 at 08:27

Since the amount of self assessment tax paybale is more te specified limit, Advance Tax is required to be paid , since advance tax is not paid hence 234C and 234B are leviable, since the return is not filed with in the due time hece 234A is also levibale, the above assessment order passed by the AO is correct except TDS, if you have TDS certificate ask the person who has dedcuted the TDS to file a revised TDS return so it can appear in form 26AS, other wise the TDS certificate issued is of waste.

 

Actually there is one more mistake in this assessment, if the TDS is not considered then the income which is shown in that particular TDS certificate should also not to be considered for assessment, so to that extent you income tax liability should be reduced. 

 

 



There are 10 Replies to this message








Related Files








Related Threads


Post your reply for Intimation u/s 143(1) - urgent please can u help



Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to login


Not a member yet ?? Click here to signup

Message







    

  • Use thank button to convey your appreciation.
  • Maintain professionalism while posting and replying to topics.
  • Try to add value with your each post.



Forum Home | Forum Portal | Member Control Center | Who is Where | Popular Threads | Today's Topic | Recent Posts | Today's Posts | Post New Topic | Thread With Files | Top Threads This Month | Forum Stats | Unreplied Threads

back to the top