LIVE GST Certification Course by CA Arun Chhajer begins 27th April. Register Now!!

How great is this ?

CS BHAVIK HARSHAD SHAH (Company Secretary) (1662 Points)

17 October 2014

Hello Friends,

Today just i got my papers & surprisely my papers marks & which i had recevied at the time of result marks are so different that i am totally amazed.

In isca paper i wrote Q7 which is correct i had already copared with suggested but still i get the marks 0

In IDT first marks is alloted is 12 then full on scrblling & allorted 6

In costing how they evealte god knows full pages i saw only cross marks nothing elas even in marks i didnt get nderstand what they written.

Now today i am 100% sure that for CA its totally on LUCK not on Dedication & full on Study....

Thanks

I am writing to this just for information i dont have any problems & any issus with this

Reply
Follow
Share

21 Replies

MAYANK AGGARWAL (B.Com, CA Final) (236 Points)
Replied 17 October 2014

Could you mail the photos or scanned copies of your answer sheets

My id is ask4mynk @ gmail.com

Sathish M (Management Accountant) (40581 Points)
Replied 17 October 2014

Mayank copies cannot be shared with any one, it tantamount to breach of ICAI rules.

GANESH MAHADEO UPALKAR (ARTICLED ASSISTANT) (256 Points)
Replied 18 October 2014

they are just controlling the results recommend to go for other course rather than ca

MAYANK AGGARWAL (B.Com, CA Final) (236 Points)
Replied 18 October 2014

@ satish - bro this is caclubindia, icai dont have any idea regarding this...

Last one member shared his answersheet with everyone..so its not a breach

You are taking it way too seriously

ISHA GOYAL (CA) (69 Points)
Replied 18 October 2014

Wat do u mean by marks are different???

Dixit (CA Final) (2405 Points)
Replied 18 October 2014

i completely agree with Bhavik

srinivas (profeesional) (93 Points)
Replied 18 October 2014

It depends on luck when you work hard. But I still agree with bhavik coz I applied for revaluation and icai took money but wothout revalung my answer paper and gave result as no discrepancy in marks

Hemant Pandit (articl assistant) (284 Points)
Replied 18 October 2014

Originally posted by : bhavik
	Hello Friends, Today just i got my papers & surprisely my papers marks & which i had receied at the time of result marks are so different that i am totally amazed. In isca paper i wrote Q7 which is correct i had already copared with suggested but still i get the marks 0 In IDT first marks is alloted is 12 then full on scrblling & allorted 6 In costing how they evealte god knows full pages i saw only cross marks nothing elas even in marks i didnt get nderstand what they written. Now today i am 100% sure that for CA its totally on LUCK not on Dedication & full on Study.... Thanks I am writing to this just for information i dont have any problems & any issus with this

bhavik... brother.. its a humble request to you please upload the scan copies here... so that it will be useful as an academic guidance to students at large..please share..

sunanda kumar patra (student) (29 Points)
Replied 18 October 2014

Share as much as you can. Nawtanki lage rakhe he.

Shiv prakash (000) (87 Points)
Replied 18 October 2014

agree with @ satish- you should not share copies of answer sheets.
& @ mayank ji... ICAI have idea about bout lots of things...
Satish your decision should not depend on what others are doing, if they are sharing it let them share...

sunanda kumar patra (student) (29 Points)
Replied 18 October 2014

Why dnt you share it.

Abhijit A Pradhan (Student) (31 Points)
Replied 18 October 2014

@ bhavik- Thats very sad friend ...m still waiting for my certified copies and I feel my papers will be the same when I get them. @ Sathish M- Sir I have been calling the concerned department for my certified copies for 4 weeks now and every week they tell me that this week you will receive them this week as they cant give any other answer. The emails have been unanswered too. It has been more than 60 months since putting in the application. The most disappointing thing in the whole matter is the inefficient manner of the co operation of the institute rather than delay in getting my copies. Is there any feasible solution which will be heeded atleast??

Abhijit A Pradhan (Student) (31 Points)
Replied 18 October 2014

* sorry I meant 60 days

Ali Raza (Student : CA - IPCC ) (163 Points)
Replied 18 October 2014

Its really sad to know that the marks awarded to u in exam are not the same which u deserve. I have heard from many students that their answer sheets are not checked properly. There are so many students who are giving their IPCC/Final exams for as many as 10-12 attempts. And what they get on the result day is FAILED. I know CA is really tough but giving lesser marks on the answer which was correct can not be justified. Even i have faced this issue. My CAFM exam was way too good and I was sure that I will get atleast 60-65 marks at any cost. But u know how much I got, only 50 marks. I dont know what to do now.