Dinesh Madan or Padhuka's?

1895 views 12 replies
Guest

Hi Everyone. I have Padhuka's and I frankly feel inbetween too much irrelevant info is given, and the language used doesnt make it easy to study. And they give VERY LITTLE BASE TO CONCEPTS at all. Its hard for a fresher to get it at first go.

While doing the rounds on CCI, I hv found ppl saying tat Dinesh Madan is very good.

Can you please tell me why Dinesh madan is good?

And if anyone disagrees with my opinon on Padhukas can you tell me where Im wrong? Or have any of you guys faced the same problem with Padhukas?

Looking forward to your comments and opinion. Thank you..

Reply Share Follow
On 14 May 2011 at 22:06 Report
Replies (12)
User Avatar

www.aubsp.com
15630 Points Joined October 2009

 

In my opinion the Institute Book is more than sufficient for scoring good marks...!!!!

 

 

CA Final ISCA Notes for May 2011

 

1 Reply
On 15 May 2011 at 00:25
Guest

Thank you .. But I forgot to say that I am IPCC...

 

Is it worth going thru Institute Mat? As InfoTech is only 50mks and the Institute Mat seems too much for tat..

Reply
On 15 May 2011 at 05:43
User Avatar

CA IN PRACTICE
16719 Points Joined May 2011

INSTITUTE MATERIAL IS GOOD

1 Reply
On 15 May 2011 at 10:15
Guest
Originally posted by : Sharon


Hi Everyone. I have Padhuka's and I frankly feel inbetween too much irrelevant info is given, and the language used doesnt make it easy to study. And they give VERY LITTLE BASE TO CONCEPTS at all. Its hard for a fresher to get it at first go.

While doing the rounds on CCI, I hv found ppl saying tat Dinesh Madan is very good.

Can you please tell me why Dinesh madan is good?

And if anyone disagrees with my opinon on Padhukas can you tell me where Im wrong? Or have any of you guys faced the same problem with Padhukas?

Looking forward to your comments and opinion. Thank you..

 

GO FOR DINESH MADAN... PADHUKA???? OH REALLY VERY IRRITATING BOOK.. I READ IT FOR MORE THAN 50 TIMES.. WITHOUT LOGIC..VERY BAD
Reply
On 15 May 2011 at 11:36
User Avatar

Article assistant
816 Points Joined December 2009

Padhuka is copied maal from institute!! Had he done this in other country, they would have definitely sued BSP and G Sekhar!!

1 Reply
On 15 May 2011 at 23:53
User Avatar

CA Final Student
291 Points Joined January 2011

go for dinesh madaan....if u don't want to refer Institute material...

 

bcoz dinesh madaan sir hasnt copied lyk odr teachrs...his buk is good...nt too mch technical, easy to understand, self-explanatry....at least i found his buk vry gud!!! i tuk tutn from him..awesme tchr...makes u undrstand so easily....

1 Reply
On 16 May 2011 at 00:51
User Avatar

CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT
16295 Points Joined January 2010
Originally posted by : future ca

INSTITUTE MATERIAL IS GOOD
Reply
On 16 May 2011 at 08:22
User Avatar

CA CS and CMA
134 Points Joined June 2010

i sugess u 2 go for dinesh madaan...as it is simple and to the point...i hv also read it n found it ultimate...n cleared my mics...

u just have to mug up the concepts n cram d whole book...

always remember ISCA paper is checked by the CAs n not MCAs...so just stdy dinesh madaan for clearing d exam...

1 Reply
On 16 May 2011 at 10:33
User Avatar

ACMA and BCOM
818 Points Joined April 2009

if u want concept wise go for dinesh madan .......

or else question and answer style go for paduka

and my view both are good ........ and for theory nothing is better than institute material.........

1 Reply
On 16 May 2011 at 11:03
Guest

Thank you everyone!!

 

Krunal, Arjit - I whole heartedly agree with what you said abt Padukas. I thot i was only person who felt lide tat.

 

And thank you Manoj for the info. I had no idea tat paper was corrected by CAs ..

 

And to all, yeah I wil also refer to Institute Material..

Reply
On 17 May 2011 at 00:10
User Avatar

student
24 Points Joined May 2011

can anyone please give me dinesh madan sir's contact no.................plzplz

Reply
On 30 July 2011 at 22:39
User Avatar

CA Final Student
291 Points Joined January 2011

dinesh madaan sir's contact numbr is:- +91-9212775272

Reply
On 31 July 2011 at 07:46


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Post Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  

Recent Threads

More recent discussions | Post

Related Threads
Loading