CA vs MBA

Dear Om,

      U are right.In PSU's, there is no dfference between CA,ICWA or even MBA. All are taken as Executive Trainees. The scope of work is the same for all the professionals. i have been in one of india's biggest PSU. The same practice is followed there also.

thanks to all for giving their valuable opinion.

one more question plz..

why the people do CA course for 5 or more year instead of MBA for only 2 years while there is no difference between CA and MBA in profession..

plz reply

CA can be completed within 4year even after +2.But MBA can be cmpleted after gradution,so MBA takes more time than CA MBA takes 5 years

i agree but chances to be success in CA in less than MBA

the result of MBA has never been 5% - 10% in final stage but CA has this imp. quality

Originally posted by : tarun
	CA can be completed within 4year even after +2.But MBA can be cmpleted after gradution,so MBA takes more time than CA MBA takes 5 years

Nice Comparison..

Good Comperision but CA is far better than MBA

It is true that there is no comperision between MBA (except good one Inst) and CA.

But why somewhere treated as same.

They have to give us more.

Also ICAI have to take some step for those PSU

Guys...do MBA of watever...but a respect that a Chartered Accountant gets cannot be compared to any other degree.