CA Piyush Jhawar (Chartered Accountant) (545 Points)
18 January 2014Guys I have Got both Padhuka and V.K.Agarawal for Audit I read surbhi bansal and practise manual twice before the november 13 exam but didnt go through it...still got 37...now which of the books should i go through...I saw padhuka...it's got quite an extensive coverage
rahul
(Chartered Accountant)
(5570 Points)
Replied 18 January 2014
Saurabh Anokhchand Jain
(Chartered Accountant)
(1043 Points)
Replied 19 January 2014
V K agrawal from Pune(A S Foundation) is also best books...
CA Raj Shah
(CA)
(347 Points)
Replied 19 January 2014
DR. URVISH SHAH BOOK IS BEST FOR SELF STUDY.
I GET 64 MARKS IN THIS ATTEMPTS JUST READING TWO TIMES.
BE SPECIFIC ANSWER WRITE IN EXAMS ARE MORE IMPORANT.
FOR THAT U HAVE TO CLEAR BY CONCEPTUALLY AND LOGICALLY ONLY THEN AND THEN U CAN GIVE ANSWER EASILY.
MANY OF MY PEOPLE ARE FAILED IN AUDITING JUST BECAUSE THEY ARE NOT UNDERSTAND WHAT THE QUESTION SAY ??? THEY UNDERSTAND ONE WORD AND WRITE EASSY TYPE ANSWER...IF THIS IS THE CASE THEN FAIL TO HONA HI THA AUDIT ME.
URVISH SHAH BOOK CONTAIN ALL AUDIT TIPS AND TECHNIQUE AND REALLY IT HELP ME ALOT.
IF ANYONE WANT XEROX OF IT THEN MAIL ME CARAJSHAH2014 @ GMAIL.COM
OR U CAN TEXT OR WHATSAPP ME ON M-9601392989
CA Raj Shah
(CA)
(347 Points)
Replied 19 January 2014
ONE MORE THING PIYUSH JHAWAR IS THAT READING DIFFERENT BOOK IS NOT THE SOLUATION TO PASS EXAM...BUT QUALITY READING IS IMPORTANT AND WHAT U GAIN FROM THAT BOOK IS ALSO IMPORTANT.
I KNOW PADUKA IS TOO LONG AND I CANT UNDERSTAND PADUKA PROPERLY AND ITS TOO MUCH LONG BOOK.
I ADVISED YOU TO PUT ASIDE ALL BOK AND JUST REFER DR.URVISH SHAH BOOK ONCE U WILL GET BETTER CONCEPTUALITY CLEAR IN AUDITING.
THANKX.
Roshan Jain
(Artical)
(124 Points)
Replied 21 January 2014
hii Raj,
i have given Nov,13 attemp. and i got very less marks in audit after studying from Surabhi Bansal.
Pls guide me in the subject for good score.
Thanx in advance.
CA Raj Shah
(CA)
(347 Points)
Replied 21 January 2014
sonal
(in Final)
(70 Points)
Replied 21 January 2014
As far as i understand Surbhi Bansal is more then sufficient to read twice for preperation before the exams n den refer once again before d day of exam....first time reference of dat book should be in depth n den revise it simply in less time as compare to first time,,, i also attempt this time n even i couldn't refer d practice mannual, RTP n even SA's due to lack of time but still i scored 55 marks in audit.....Its better to revise the same book again n again then to refer different books.....
When u revised d same thing again n again, u can retain it in a perfect manner n complete contents....
you should also identify dat whether is there any default in ur writing approch or presentation then u should also work on it for better results....
All the best
CAclubindia
