manik (ca in practice) (420 Points)
16 June 2011we had received from our clearing and forwarding agent a documents a invoice(including service tax) and a debit note for reimbursement of expenses. my question is on which amount tds has to be deducted whether only on invoice or total payment made to C and F agent.
CA ADITYA SHARMA
(CA IN PRACTICE )
(16719 Points)
Replied 16 June 2011
TDS IS TO BE DEDUCTED ON THE AMOUNT WHICH IS BEING CREDITED TO PARTY AC, FOR PAYMENT
valji
(Accounts manager-MBA)
(2150 Points)
Replied 16 June 2011
if seprate column is given for remibursement with supporting then not deducted TDS on the same but for this check all supporting
if combined bill given not made any sepration for reimbursement then tds should be ducated on whole amt of bill
if possible ask your c& f agennt give separte bill for reimbursement
Payments to Clearing and Forwarding agents for carriage of goods are subject to TDS. The Clearing and Forwarding agents themselves are also liable to deduct tax on payments to a carrier of goods
TDS has to be deducted under section 194C for contract work. In case the CHA gives combined bill for reimbusements and service charges, TDS has to beducted on whole bill.
However,if separate debit note is issued for reimbursements and service charges bill is issued separately then TDS is applicable on the bill amount only and not on the debit note
CS,CA F,Numrologi TusharSampat
(CS CA F Numerologist Astrologer Graphologist Face reader Vastu Expert)
(85930 Points)
Replied 16 June 2011
TDS IN UR CASE IS TO BE DEDUCTED ON GROSS AMOUNT U/S 194C.
Suresh
(Service)
(91 Points)
Replied 17 June 2011
Agree with Valji, a practical guy. Any reimbursement claim with proper supporting documents no need to make TDS.
amitmehta_ca
(CA, CMA)
(99 Points)
Replied 17 June 2011
Dear Manik, Please refer to circular no. 715 dated 8 aug 1995. According to the circular reimbursement of expenses cannot be deducted from the total amount of bill for the purpose of deduction of TDS. Please also refer to Willmar Schwabe India(p) ltd. Vs. ITO where the delhi bench of Income tax Appellate Tribunal examined the scope of above mentioned circular. It was held that reimbursement of expenses for which bill is separately raised did not attract deduction of TDS u/s 194J.
Following points to be noted.
1. TDS deductible on gross amount if consolidated bill was raised inclusive of service tax if any.
2. No deduction of TDS deductible if separate invoice raised for reimbursement of expenses.
CA Mohit Saxena
(FINANCE MANAGER)
(343 Points)
Replied 17 June 2011
| Originally posted by : amitmehta_ca | ||
 |
Dear Manik, Please refer to circular no. 715 dated 8 aug 1995. According to the circular reimbursement of expenses cannot be deducted from the total amount of bill for the purpose of deduction of TDS. Please also refer to Willmar Schwabe India(p) ltd. Vs. ITO where the delhi bench of Income tax Appellate Tribunal examined the scope of above mentioned circular. It was held that reimbursement of expenses for which bill is separately raised did not attract deduction of TDS u/s 194J. Following points to be noted. 1. TDS deductible on gross amount if consolidated bill was raised inclusive of service tax if any. 2. No deduction of TDS deductible if separate invoice raised for reimbursement of expenses. |
 |
agreed
CA Pawan Sharma
(CA.)
(65 Points)
Replied 17 June 2011
If the expenses mentioned in the bill 'SEPARATELY'
If the expenses 'NOT' mentioned in the bill 'SEPARATELY'
nikhil pansare
(student)
(33 Points)
Replied 18 June 2011
tds in maid only on net amt +service tax not on expenses on which reimbursement is maid
CAclubindia
