LIVE GST Certification Course by CA Arun Chhajer begins 21st April. Register Now!!

complaint against dummy articleship

(Guest)

HI,

I am doing my articleship from a local firm in Mumbai.At the time of joining this firm, my CA had told me that they had 40+ articles in all. On the basis of this statement, I thought that it would be a very good firm & I joined thos firm but afterwards I realised that most of the articles are dummy & the workexposure is not good which he had promised me at the time of joining.I feel that he has really cheated me. I want to raise the complaint regarding his providing dummy to the students..Can anyone tell me the procedure for raising the complaint?

Reply
Follow
Share

57 Replies

CMA KNVV Sri Vidya - Sri Kanth (C.A.Final (New) ICWAI FINAL (New)) (11269 Points)
Replied 01 June 2009

Hey preeti before givin a complaint just think a while

he is a chartered accountant

he also know the ways to escape

so becareful

(Guest)

try Media.....

Mohan Verma (Assistant Manager - Finance & Accounts) (4328 Points)
Replied 01 June 2009

Hi preeti

vidya is right

Please think before giving a complaint against CA Firm

CA Mohd Gouse (Chartered Accountant) (497 Points)
Replied 02 June 2009

1 Like

Dipendar (CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT) (291 Points)
Replied 02 June 2009

Originally posted by :Preeti
"	HI, I am doing my articleship from a local firm in Mumbai.At the time of joining this firm, my CA had told me that they had 40+ articles in all. On the basis of this statement, I thought that it would be a very good firm & I joined thos firm but afterwards I realised that most of the articles are dummy & the workexposure is not good which he had promised me at the time of joining.I feel that he has really cheated me. I want to raise the complaint regarding his providing dummy to the students..Can anyone tell me the procedure for raising the complaint?	"

Hi Preeti

I dont think it would be a good idea to complaint on 2 perspective. No. 1 if you do complain and succeed than it would mean that in that case other students who have taken dummy there would be barred from CA Examinations and I hope you would not want to harm them. No. 2 Chances are that you would not succeed as said by Vidya b'coz a CA knows how to escape and then he might even claim you to be a dummy as he may falsely give your attendance to Institute.

So its better not to go in your decision and seek for other alternative

Darshit (CA Final) (964 Points)
Replied 02 June 2009

I think you should complaint, dont worry atleast you can get a transfer and 1 more thig no Chartered Accountant has that guts to screw up ur life, 1 more thign, this 3 years are for learning, first take a transfer and then complaint, you will be safe on both the ends and wud have a gud career.

Dipendar (CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT) (291 Points)
Replied 02 June 2009

Originally posted by :Darsht*
"	I think you should complaint, dont worry atleast you can get a transfer and 1 more thig no Chartered Accountant has that guts to screw up ur life, 1 more thign, this 3 years are for learning, first take a transfer and then complaint, you will be safe on both the ends and wud have a gud career.	"

My dear friend Darsh*t I guess has forgotten that transfer has been prohibited by the Institute now so if your CA only desires then only can u get transfer

CWA ROHIT (CA FINAL ) (34 Points)
Replied 02 June 2009

hi preeti,

i thnk vidya is all right because i know a case where chartered accountant was wrong but the decision was in favour of ca not for article. so before do anything first u think deeply in this then do anything against ca.

CA Tilak Raj Sharma (Practising CA in Solan (H.P.)) (6374 Points)
Replied 02 June 2009

Preeti, Please tell me why do like to make a complaint. If you wants the dummy seat then ask him for that. You cannot take transfer. Dummy articleship is demanded by articles , its not offered by us (CAs).

Please think before twice, thrice before you do anything.

All the firms have dummy articles, so don't expect a decision in your favour.

Karthik (C A Student) (219 Points)
Replied 02 June 2009

Mr. Tilak Raj Sharma, I hope you know what you mean by what you just said...You are openly supporting DUMMY articleship ?

VIJAY BAJAJ (ARTICLE ASSISTANT) (72 Points)
Replied 02 June 2009

hi preeti,

According to me whatever suggestions y have received till now Vidya advice was the best and Mr. Tilak raj advice was worst won. If u r thinking that he providing dummy at free of cost then think again since nothing comes free. Even if u ask for dummy he will deny since he has got cheap labour which he can use as he wants. there would some other articles also working speak to them and if they r really with u only then take some action otherwise u might end up destroying your career.

Even if u wants to fight make your prepare mentally that much enough to fight for your right since the persons who r on dummy would themselves say in the ca institute that u yourself r a dummy article and they r not and would provide false proof for that.

Think yourself what is good for u so that if something bad happens then do not have to blame anyone.

CA Tilak Raj Sharma (Practising CA in Solan (H.P.)) (6374 Points)
Replied 02 June 2009

Hi All,

I am not supporting dummy articleship. Yaar you all students, complaint when your CA is hard, when they don't give leaves, when they don't give you work and exposure and when they give others dummy articleship and not to you.

I am not favouring anything. Just concerntrate your own training and study. Don't interfere in others work.

CA Tilak Raj Sharma (Practising CA in Solan (H.P.)) (6374 Points)
Replied 02 June 2009

I am just saying that if you want to complaint then please think both positive and negative point of your cpmplaint.

Karthik (C A Student) (219 Points)
Replied 02 June 2009

Sir... we are all human beings...so obviously we compare ourselves with others !! I am sorry to say, but chartered accountants are the main ppl who compare themselves with other CAs...you must be aware of that. So my point is that the institute, instead of penalising students, should FIRST PENALISE THE CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT WHO IS PROVIDING THE SERVICE OF DUMMY ARTICLESHIP !!! as a CA is suppossed to be a person who sets an example to the society !! if he himself indulges in these FRAUDULENT activities, what can we expect from those who enroll under him for their articleship ?