Clash between revised schedule vi and as 4

AS 2100 views 14 replies

Dear Sir,

Referring to para 4.3.4 of the guidance note on revised schedule VI to the Companies Act, it states that proposed dividend declared by a subsidiary company after the date of balance sheet should no longer be included in the said balance sheet as an adjusting event.  As per AS 9, dividend should be recognised only when the right to receive dividend is established as on the balance sheet date.  My question to you is that doesn't this provision clash with the provisions of para 8.5 of AS 4 which states that proposed dividend, even though declared after the date of the balance sheet, should be treated as an adjusting event and should reflect in the balance sheet. The guidance note in para 4.1.1 clearly specifies that in case of incongruence between the guidance note and any accounting standards, the requirement of the accounting standard shall prevail.

In the light of above provisions, kindly clarify me the correct accounting treatment.
 

Replies (14)

I think Accounting Standard 4 should Prevail.

no proposed divident cant be shown in b/s

i think there is notofication, i am not remebering exactly.... but i read somewhere k AS 4 will prevail.. wait for expert's comment

it was clearly mentioned in the notification issued by ROC, wherever there is a conflict between accounting standard issued by ICAI and Revised schedule VI, Accounting standard will prevail over it and requirements given under Revised schedule Vi are minimum in presentation of financial statements.

Under revised schedule VI proposed divided is required to be disclosed in notes on accounts only.

https://www.mca.gov.in/Ministry/pdf/Schedule_VI_28feb2011.pdf

just go to above link read general instruction no.1 u r doubt will be clear

Sequence of Applicability

 

1. AS will be given 1st preferance

2. Companies Act if AS is silent

3. Schedule VI if Companies Act is silent

 

LET ME MAKE IT EASY FOR YOU.....THE LAST POST WAS RI8.

IN ADDITION TO ABOVE.....YOU MAY GO FOR SURBHI BANSAL'S LATEST EDITION WHERE IT HAS BEEN CLARIFIED THAT IN AND ACCORDING TO SCHEDULE VI (NOT REVISED SCHEDULE VI) PROPOSED DIVIDEND=CURRENT LIABILITY THOUGH IT WAS NOT IN EXISTENCE ON THE BALANCE SHEET DATE.

I HOPE I WAS ABLE TO HELP YOU.

Ya if there is a conflict between Accounting Standards and Revised schedule then accounting standards prevail.......as it is already clarified that :-

1- Give preference for AS

2. If AS is silent then Companies Act.

3. If companies Act And AS is silent then Revised Schedule VI.

Thank you all for your responses

Hello Friends,

I think i will help u,

As per revised schedule vi, P.D will not be disclose under balancesheet. Which is differ from AS-4....For solving down this problem icai are taking steps ...for it icai is changing as-4 and for it icai is already created exposure draft for AS-4 limited revison..I hereby attaching herewith exposure draft...Due to this...its clear that icai intention is to convert AS-4 par with Revised Schedule-6. So its clear that proposed dividend will not be mentioned under Balance sheet.

https://220.227.161.86/28045expasb290912a.pdf

Thanks,

Hello Friends,

I think i will help u,

As per revised schedule vi, P.D will not be disclose under balancesheet. Which is differ from AS-4....For solving down this problem icai are taking steps ...for it icai is changing as-4 and for it icai is already created exposure draft for AS-4 limited revison..I hereby attaching herewith exposure draft...Due to this...its clear that icai intention is to convert AS-4 par with Revised Schedule-6. So its clear that proposed dividend will not be mentioned under Balance sheet.

https://220.227.161.86/28045expasb290912a.pdf

Thanks,

yes AS-4 come in to picture in this case.  AS will prevail over schedule-vi

AS 4 says about the declaration dividend by a company but revised schedule says about the dividend received from the subsidiary then y there is a conflict.


CCI Pro

Leave a Reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  

Company
Featured 14 April 2026
GST CONSULTANT

Abhishek G Agrawal & Co.

Korba

CA Final

View Details
Company
Featured 19 March 2026
Article Assistant

Gupta Sachdeva & Co. Chartered Accountants

New Delhi

CA Final

View Details
Company
Featured 12 March 2026
Customer Relationship Executive

TAXLET

Calicut

B.Com

View Details
Company
Featured 28 March 2026
CA Final

Ashok Amol & Associates

New Delhi

CA Final

View Details
Company
Featured 28 March 2026
Accountant

Ashok Amol & Associates

New Delhi

B.Com

View Details
Company
Featured 13 April 2026
GST CONSULTANCY

Abhishek G Agrawal & Co.

Korba

CA Final

View Details
Company
Featured 14 March 2026
Article Trainee

N N V Satish&co

Hyderabad

CA Inter

View Details
Company
Featured 14 March 2026
Associate CA

N N V Satish&co

Hyderabad

CA

View Details