Subscribe to Email


Discussion > Income Tax > Can an audit is required under sec.44AB for insurance agent     Post New Topic

Pages : 1 2


There are 10 Replies to this message



Jaspreet Singh
CA PCC STUDENT
[ Scorecard : 240]
Posted On 02 December 2009 at 23:01 Report Abuse

Report Abuse / Feedback


Name
Email
Subject
Message

Verify Verify Code 
  

Note : The above form can be used to intimate the moderators regarding abuse of the platform.


Plez tell me that an audit is required under sec 44AB of Income Tax Act 1961 for an insurance agent if its income exceeds Rs. 10 lacs a year?


Share This


CA krishna Kamthe
Partner
[ Scorecard : 100]
Posted On 03 December 2009 at 10:39

As per Guidance note on Tax Audit

for Profession limit is 10 lacs and for Business it is 40 lacs for Tax Audit

Insurance Agent  is comming under Business so Rule is to cross sales 40 lacs

so no Tax Audit Apply.



CA. Varun Soni
Chartered Accountant
[ Scorecard : 194]
Posted On 03 December 2009 at 12:01

i agree with CA krishna Kamthe
 



Sunil
Trader
[ Scorecard : 1725]
Posted On 07 December 2009 at 16:13

Jaspreetji, I have posted this elsewhere in this Forum. However, you apply your mind on the following basis:-

 

As per Income Tax Act, profession INCLUDES a vocation.

 

What is actually happening is a confusion of word Business, Profession, Vocation. All these are OCCUPATION of a person.

 

Real Estate Commission is a Business Receipt. All DTAAs recognise independent agents as doing business.

 

Architect, Chartered Accountant, Lawyers, Insurance Actuary,Company Secretary, Cost Accountant etc., Engineers, Doctors etc. are all recognised professions as they have memberships to associations that have a legal or parliamentary sanction without which they cannot practice in the field. Any person doing the work that is in the domain of these professions will also be deemed to be in these professions as per Income Tax. Therefore if you are not a lawyer but charge for legal advice, you are a legal professional. The department is least concerned whether you are eligible or not in your profession.

 

Besides these, there are also occupations that are deemed as professions. These are interior designers, models, film artistes, artists (painting). These do not have legally sanctioned bodies although they may have unions or associations (not by act of parliament). These too are considered as professions for Income Tax India.

 

Insurance Agent is a dependent agent carrying on his own business. Insurance Broker is an independent broker carrying on his own business. The receipt for both is identical and would be a business receipt. They are only licensed to do the business. If a business is regulated by license it does not become a profession.

 

Life will be much simpler for you if you consider the words business, profession, vocation and occupation as four different words. once you identify the difference and the thin dividing line between the latter 3, you will get the hang of it.

 



Venkat M
Practicing CA
[ Scorecard : 100]
Posted On 03 February 2010 at 11:51

Tax audit will not apply in this case.



amit jain
ca final
[ Scorecard : 241]
Posted On 22 February 2010 at 21:36

audit would be necessary if receipts from profession exceeds the prescribed limit...but insurance agent does not come in professionals



Amol Gopal Kabra (CA,CS,DISA)
Practicing CA
[ Scorecard : 1169]
Posted On 22 February 2010 at 22:03

Insurance Agent is not a professional. His receipts shall be considered under business income.



C.Balaji
Student
[ Scorecard : 1616]
Posted On 23 February 2010 at 07:30

I do think that Insurance agent is not a professional........His income will be considered under business income.....so no tax audit......



Ajay Garg
CA FINAL
[ Scorecard : 67]
Posted On 20 July 2010 at 20:15

PLEASE TELL ME THAT ABOVE WHICH LIMIT RECEIPTS, BOOKS OF ACCOUNT MUST BE MAINTAIN U/S 44AA.



Ajay Garg
CA FINAL
[ Scorecard : 67]
Posted On 20 July 2010 at 20:33

IF ANY ONE HAVE CIRCULARS, GUIDANCE NOTE NO. ETC. ABOUT INSURANCE AGENT IS COVERED UNDER BUSINESS, THAN PLEASE GIVE ME SUCH COPY OR NUMBER OF SUCH REFERENCE.

 

BECAUSE I THINK SUCH RECEIPT FROM AGENCY IS COVERED UNDER PROFESSIONAL HEAD.





Related Files


 


Previous Thread Next Thread


Related Threads


 

Post your reply for Can an audit is required under sec.44AB for insurance agent



Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to login


Not a member yet ?? Click here to signup

Message