Live Course on Drafting of Appeal and Reply of Penalty Notice by CA Sachin Sinha. Register Now!!

ca results and valuation system

qarni (student) (1220 Points)

18 October 2007

dear &near all,

Is cA procedure of valuation and result decleration satisfied.

If they r correct .Why dont they return the corrected papers unlike other universities to see and satisfy even by taking fees only.They must publish the top ranker papers in newsletters or they should be made available so that others can see that approach.

Reply
Follow
Share

24 Replies

qarni (student) (1220 Points)
Replied 18 October 2007

no one is discussing about this !!!!!!!!!!!!!11

1 Like

denziljacob (18 Points)
Replied 18 October 2007

I absolutely agree with wat qarni says.Institute shud do away with old age systems & Definitely be more transperant in valuation procedures.

Prakash Popat (3134 Points)
Replied 18 October 2007

Yes all of us would like to C beauty behind Veil.

Shaily Jain (Chartered Accountants) (1054 Points)
Replied 18 October 2007

this is argueless.........n pl faith on ur institute

CA PRIKSHIT WADHWA (CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT) (339 Points)
Replied 18 October 2007

OF WHICH FAITH U R TALKING ABOUT MS. JAIN, THE FAITH WHICH WAS SOLD BY THE COACHING CENTRES FEW MONTHS BACK FOR JUST FEW BUCKS. IF THE INSTITUTE HAS PROPER VALUATION SYSTEM THEN WHY DOESN'T THEY SHOW US THE CORRECTED PAPERS. WHY THERE IS ONLY PROCDURE FOR REVERIFICATION AND NOT FOR REVALUATION.

CMA Kiran Kumar K.V. (Research Associate) (64 Points)
Replied 19 October 2007

Hai, I Agree With all of u.But Think Universities have particular limitations under which there are few colleges & it makes it possible from them to permit revaluation & give valuated papers photocopies at some cost. But,don't forget our ICAI ha or anyother professional body has one hea office & several Branches in the stated regions & if u want to have get valuated papers where will u go toRegional head office or to main office? for eg. if a student in dubai want to reverify his papers where will he come? Just Think Once & Have Faith In Institute & Paper Valuaters.If U Write Correctly They Will Surely Give Good Marks To U. Hope u all got it.& pl. stop thiking of all these & prepare well for ur exams. All The Best. CMA Kiran Kumar K.V.

(Guest)

hai i am also agree i want to see my copy after checking becoz from so many times i am writing still i didn't get my result pass only for some marks, now i decided nov. 07 is my last attempt, when i will see my result in jan 08 if it is fail i won't write again, plz advice me what i will do

(Guest)

REPLY IN MAIL ID PLZ I AM GETTING TENSE ABOUT MY RESULT

CA Chaitanya (PRACTISING CA) (4283 Points)
Replied 24 December 2007

IF you write correctly, there is no need for yor people to turn back. Lets have trust in the institute.

CA. Shikha (Chartered Accountant) (4143 Points)
Replied 28 December 2007

I also believe that corrected papaers should be sent to the students so that they can know in what areas they are lacking behind.

Ramkrishna Mokashi (Chartered Accountant) (734 Points)
Replied 29 December 2007

ITS NOT QUESTION OF FAITH. THERE ARE PEOPLE WHO ARE FAILING AFTER MILLIONS OF EFFORTS, IF THEY ARE PROVIDED WITH THE PAST PAPERS, THEY CAN BREAK THE CHAIN. THERE IS A PROVISION FOR RECHECKING, BUT NOT TRANSPARENT AS IT SHOULD BE. FURTHER, I AGREE THAT PAPERS OF THOSE WHO GOT RANK SHOULD BE PUBLISHED, EITHER; IN JOURNAL OR, ON WEBSITE OR, THROUGH PUBLICATION LIKE RTP/SUGG.ANS. THIS WILL HELP BOTH RE-APPEARERS AND FIRST TIME APPEARERS. I WONDER WHAT STUDENT ASSOCIATIONS LIKE WICASA, CICASA, SICASE ETC, ARE DOING..

(Guest)

I totally agree of what Ram has written. i think this was a very prudent question. But it cannot be possible by overnight. the only thing we can do is to make personal effort without bothering about the functioning of institute .

DMC (Student) (364 Points)
Replied 03 January 2008

I do not believe that the institute does not correct the papers properly or controls the results by purposely failing students. I can say this by my personal exp. in PE-2 exams. I have cleared my PE-2 in two attempts for the first attempt I did not study and wrote all crap and failed. For the second attempt I studied and wrote well and got more than 60 pc marks May be the situation is different in Finals

(Guest)

i was waiting my result again i failed wt should i do now,this mark is not, wt i was expecting. If i will recheck wt i have to do,whether any change will come or not in my mark.this is not my right mark wt i have written,again 6 subject in pe2 how i will prepare plz reply me