Live Course on Drafting of Appeal and Reply of Penalty Notice by CA Sachin Sinha. Register Now!!

CA or CS ?

rakesh (3 yr) (67 Points)

09 August 2011

my frn is a c.s working in a reputed company and earns a salary around 40000 . but his fern who is a c.a in the same company earns 100000. both have equal in terms of expierence . i want to pursue C.S alongside LLB but due to salary constraint i feel i have to go ahead with C.A. rather than C.S. Pls guide me....

Reply
Follow
Share

15 Replies

AMIT MISHRA (Legal Professional) (393 Points)
Replied 09 August 2011

Dear Rakesh,

Both are respectable proffesions.It all depends upon our attitude and interest. According to a survey by times of India 1 year back(January 2010) LLB/CS was the 2nd most payed profession in India. It depends upon your interest in law or accounting(C.A.) and the place you are pursuing law from(IT MAKES A GREAT DIFFERENCE)

I would suggest you to go for C.S. and pursue a 5yr Law from a good law school(ILS PUNE, BVP OR THE NATIONAL LAW COLLEGES). If not then 3yr from DU.

MORE IMPORTANTLY ITS NOT ABOUT WHAT YOU ARE DOING ITS ABOUT HOW YOU ARE DOING. QUALITY NOT THE QUANTITY

Thanks & Regads

Amit Mishra

9555681626

BSamrish & Co.

New Delhi

3 Like

Parmod Rawat (B.COM,MBA,CWA Inter) (401 Points)
Replied 09 August 2011

Hi Rakesh as per my personal view you should go with CA if you can do it because CA future prospectus is too wide than C.S & moreover the salary conceren every CA is getting much more then C.S so it would be bettter if you go with C.A because so many organisation C.A's are doing the work of C.S also & area of work is too wider then C.S as i am not criticising C.S profession but it is real fact as now a days C.S demand is very less but one thing you should keep in mind that C.A study very much tuffer then C.S...

but if you interest in law & company matter then go with C.S other wise you should go with CA or ICWA

1 Like

RG - A Helping Hand (Company Secretary) (13867 Points)
Replied 09 August 2011

This is very unfortunate that salary is the sole criteria for you to choose a carrer for yourself. You have no clue about your own interest, vision...

Just to let you know in my company my senior CS (my boss) is holding top mgt position and 7 chartered Accountant are reporting to him and in the team 3 chartered Accountants are reporting to me only. There is no need to say that they are drawing much less than us. But we all are gud friends and there is almost no boss-employee relationship.

In the next company position may be reverse like you have mentioned so the criteria is not the salary or position but your own attitude and vision to contribute to the growth of your company.

So open your eyes and explore yourself and your interest to excel in life.

Rgds

7 Like

jeets (CS ) (461 Points)
Replied 09 August 2011

Hi Rakesh,

I agree with Pramod, you should go for CA. I myself being a CS+LLB..always feel that CA degree is like a holy grail.

Its not only about salary, other things taken into consideration.. CA is always the better option.

Thanks

ACMA.Manish Sarawgi (Assistant Manager (F&A)) (109 Points)
Replied 09 August 2011

Correct CA is better than CS

Ankit Jain (.) (22 Points)
Replied 09 August 2011

Hello frnds i am ankit jain. i clear IPCC exam and i want to get ARTICAL SHIP IN DELHI in a company please help me and guide me bcz i dont hv any knowledge about DELHI.

Pranjal (Student CA IPC / IPCC) (531 Points)
Replied 09 August 2011

Go for CA,you won't repend in future.If one look at the history both CWA & CS seemed to have originated from ICAI only.While ICWAI came up in 1956,ICSI came up in 1980 only.You can safely bet CA is lika IAS among commerce stream professions.

1 Like

Jogendra Dutta (Student IPCC) (28 Points)
Replied 09 August 2011

Salary should not be the criteria to choose a profession,go for the one where you have interest,if you go for CA only because of its salary prospects you may not be successful,my only advise is go for the profession which you are comfortable with not with the one which yeilds the most.

1 Like

Mintu Ghosh (Accounts Officer) (21 Points)
Replied 10 August 2011

Hi Rakesh

I agree with Amit, you should go for CS. And if you do LLB with CS then the salary band should be better than CA.

CA Srinivas.Gali (Chartered Accountant) (245 Points)
Replied 10 August 2011

Hi rakesh

I agree with richank garg

which one is better and salary not a criteria professional like you

every one has to consider their intrests, vision, ambtions ,saticifaction in work

to earn only money there are so many other ways, even your qulification not required for that

HIREN VYAS (COMPANY SECRETARY + LL.B.) (28 Points)
Replied 10 August 2011

friend

really for the choosing the c.a. or c.s. the salary is not only constrain but your real interest is consider and which subject is more interesting for you is vital. other wise both profession has their equal recognisation and merit and both have considerable income

Vaibhav Chauhan (Student - CA Final) (26 Points)
Replied 10 August 2011

hiii ankit jain,

first u hav to opt whether u want to go for a mediokar firm in which u can learn & get time for studies & classes alsoor 1 of big 4 which don't let you to go 4 classes freely.

u can get touch wid me through mail in regard of joining as i can let u join both of the above options

here's ma mail id.- lavditi @ gmail.com.

Vaibhav Chauhan

1 Like