Live Course on Drafting of Appeal and Reply of Penalty Notice by CA Sachin Sinha. Register Now!!

Ca final grp 2 books??

gaurav (CA Finale) (226 Points)

30 November 2011

Pls. suggest reference books for May 12 attempt providing conceptual clarity & from exam scoring point of view:-

Costing- Padhuka or Sanjay Agarwal?

Isca-Dinesh Madan or Padhuka or Manish Valechha?

Direct Taxes-Vinod Gupta or T.N.Manoharan or Padhuka(Suggest 2 books if required)?

Indirect Taxes-(Bangar + Compiler) or Deepak Gupta or Padhuka(Suggest 2 books if required)?

{From where to study IDT Case Laws as case laws in Bangar is voluminous to revise in exam time??

How Is Padhuka for Taxes during revision time?? Pls. suggest in detail..}

Reply
Follow
Share

5 Replies

CA VISHAL RANA,CS,B.Com,AMFI (Chartered Accountant in Whole Time Practice) (4354 Points)
Replied 30 November 2011

(1) FR - vijay kumar,
(2) AS - D. S. Rawat,
(3) SFM - S.D Bala
(4) AUDIT - For SA - V.K aggarwal
(5) LAW - munish bhandari only,,,
(6) Costing & OR - sanjay aggarwal and practice manual ,
(7 ) ISCA - Dinesh Maddan
(8) DT - vinod gupta
(9) IDT - banger

rahul (Chartered Accountant) (5570 Points)
Replied 30 November 2011

Costing- Padhuka, Study Material and PM
ISCA - Manish Vlaechha plus PM (The book perfectly covers all aspects of ISCA, added with examples, diagrams, memory codes....No need to refer study material)
Direct Taxes- T.N.Manoharan Plus Summary Module of Vinod Gupta
Indirect Taxes - N S Govindan for Concepta Plus Padhuka for detailed Study and past exam Qs.

1 Like

Sushil (CA Final Student) (2571 Points)
Replied 30 November 2011

Costing - 1. First read ICAI module throughly whether you have joined classes or not. 2. Then refer ICAI Practice Manual. Revise it atleast 2 times. 3. Final polish with last current RTP + previous RTP.

ISCA - Major problem in this subject is understanding the Questions in exam hall. Padhuka is the better one as it is given in Q/A format and it also covers all RTP case studies.

Direct Taxes - Vinod Gupta's Module are very nice for understanding the concepts and its solved exam questions are very helpful. It also provide Summary Module but make sure you prepare your own notes atleast for Chapter CG, PGBP and Wealth Tax. Rest you can refer Summary Module.

IDT - Bangar is better for this subject but it requires 3 reading to get grip over the subject.

Case Laws DT & IDT - ICAI Case Law Booklet + Amdt Book + Current RTP.

1 Like

(Guest)

in dt bangur is also best for exam orient.. in isca u can refer module for good marks no option like dinesh madan etc.

gaurav (CA Finale) (226 Points)
Replied 02 December 2011

Thx a ton sushil bro... u just confirmed d way i planned to study Grp 2 except for IDT in which i buy ur point, but its difficult to revise from bangar during exams so shud i get a Compiler for IDT for revisions??

Also wud probably buy Padhuka for Costing in addition,to refer to previous exam questions and RTPs...Pls. verify if i am correct??