vaibhav (student) (24 Points)
18 February 2009hiiiiiiiiii
my name is vaibhav jain
i'm made to do the personal works for my ca Fetching vegetables for his wife depositig cheques ans chalans for him ,getting papers photocopied, serving the clients is that all for which i have been ???????
am i his article or his slave!!!! adding to the furies is that i am made to work WITHOUT STIPEND -GIVE CASH IN RETURN OF CHEQUE
CAN I KNOW FOR WAT A ARTICLE IS FOR?
wat are his duties, work,responslibities
PLS HELP ME OUT
nayana
(N.A)
(216 Points)
Replied 19 February 2009
u should have self respect n u r self respect should not be heart ,u should tk a trf or better to tok to ICAI or Chairman of WICASA they will help.what ever stated above is true then u should tk some action.best of luck
Harshvardhan Arora
(Article)
(158 Points)
Replied 21 February 2009
its not about being self respect or being a slave. its not just about ur fututre but other artticles also under him. if u can prove this , i suggest u to make a written complaint with the ICAi to look into such areas of concern. Am sure some action would be taken against him.
As regards work like photocopying n deposit of challans is concerned, if the office is not too big, then you would have to do it sometimes, its not slavery. BUt things like fetching vegetables for his family, and serving clients is something which is not acceptable.
Dont take it lightly and do go against such treatment, And the fact about not being paid is strictly unethical.. Wish u luck
suneet
(CA FINAL)
(421 Points)
Replied 22 February 2009
ICAI is so stupid that it has not enacted any good and hard provisions for betterment of articles , ensuring them a good work and ensuring that they get their stipends on time
i feel sorry for you but i tell you vaibhav about 70% of students are NOT satisfied of their training
this is a big loophole in our system
only the person who has "jan pechan " with his ca except some exceptions are only satisfied . THEY ARE GIVEN IMPOTANCE OVER OTHER ARTICLED IN ASSIGNMENT OF WORK.
this the misery of our articleship
everybody has to be a slave for 3 and half years
dipak
( ca final student)
(427 Points)
Replied 08 October 2009
|
ICAI is so stupid that it has not enacted any good and hard provisions for betterment of articles , ensuring them a good work and ensuring that they get their stipends on time i feel sorry for you but i tell you vaibhav about 70% of students are NOT satisfied of their training this is a big loophole in our system only the person who has "jan pechan " with his ca except some exceptions are only satisfied . THEY ARE GIVEN IMPOTANCE OVER OTHER ARTICLED IN ASSIGNMENT OF WORK. this the misery of our articleship everybody has to be a slave for 3 and half years |
ITS REALLY TRUE
harry
(Awaiting ca final results)
(461 Points)
Replied 08 October 2009
Articleship is just about providing cheap labour.
CA GIRISH
(Chartered Accountant)
(1796 Points)
Replied 14 October 2009
SORRY HARRY I DONT AGREE WITH ..ITS NOT ALL ABOUT PROVIDING CHEAP LABOUR....THOUGH THERE R SOME CASES LIKE VAIBHAV BUT MANY OF FRIENDS HAVE KICK START JOBS ON D BASIS OF THERE ARTICLES N MARKS...
Amol Gopal Kabra (CA,CS,DISA)
(Practicing CA)
(8539 Points)
Replied 17 October 2009
| Originally posted by :suneet | ||
| " | ICAI is so stupid that it has not enacted any good and hard provisions for betterment of articles , ensuring them a good work and ensuring that they get their stipends on time i feel sorry for you but i tell you vaibhav about 70% of students are NOT satisfied of their training this is a big loophole in our system only the person who has "jan pechan " with his ca except some exceptions are only satisfied . THEY ARE GIVEN IMPOTANCE OVER OTHER ARTICLED IN ASSIGNMENT OF WORK. this the misery of our articleship everybody has to be a slave for 3 and half years |
" |
I dont agree you on this Mr. Suneet.
ICAI is not stupid. Its that you are not aware of your rights. Who says that ICAI has not made any strict rules as regards to articles. Please refer the Chartered Accountants Act and Regulations. there are several regulations regarding articleshio training.
Also if considering what Mr. Vaibhav has said is true, you can find all there is provision in the Regulations for such acts of Chartered Accountants. Its not ICAI's fault if you are not aware of the regulations made by it for articled clerks. In this case Mr. Vaibhav should lodge a written complaint to Disciplinary Committee of ICAI seeking justice for such misbehaviour of the Employer.
So Mr. Vaibhav, its advice to you to be aware about your rights and obligations and to Mr. Suneet, not to speak abuse about ICAI without knowing any regulatory information.
CA Amol G. Kabra
CAclubindia
