Amount to be deposit
Arpit Jain (Employee) (62 Points)
09 November 2016Arpit Jain (Employee) (62 Points)
09 November 2016
Hemen Parekh
(3 Points)
Replied 10 November 2016
A Face Saving Formula ?
With reference to demonetization of old currency notes , Government , yesterday came out with the following clarification :
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
By 30th Dec , you are welcome to deposit any amount of OLD notes in your bank account ,
BUT,
If that deposit exceeds Rs 2.5 lakhs , you will need to pay on the excess , 30 % tax plus 200 % penalty
AND
possible prosecution / jail term
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Having introduced the easy INCOME DECLARATION SCHEME earlier and having repeatedly warned the Black Money holders of dire consequences if they do not come clean , it is understandable that the Government has to live up to its words !
With this clarification , one thing is very clear
No one holding crores of Black Money , is going to come forward and deposit more than Rs 2.5 lakh in his bank account !
Even if he has that 230 % ( tax + penalty ) in WHITE / OFFICIAL bank account , who wants to go to jail ?
So , what will they do ?
Of course , BURN UP those old currency notes in order to destroy all evidence !
Now Black Money stashed away locally are estimated at Rs 30 lakh*crore ( @ 15 % - 20 % of our GDP )
Let us say , only 33 % of these are in the form of CASH ( balance being locked up in Gold / Land etc )
This means , some Rs 10 lakh*crore worth of Rs 500 / 1000 notes will get burned in the coming days - adding to air pollution !
Can something be done to , put these money to some PRODUCTIVE USE ( without putting those Black Money holders behind bars ) ?
Let me provide a context , as follows :
A person convicted of having committed a murder and punished with death penalty , says,
" I know I must suffer the consequences of my heinous crime . But after I am declared dead , please donate my heart for transplant and save someone who will , otherwise die "
I believe our Society will accept such an offer gracefully , even if coming from a murderer
MY SUGGESTION :
Please allow those Black Money Holders to deposit those Rs 10 lakh*crore in bank accounts created specifically for :
* Prime Ministers Relief Fund
* Armed Forces Relief Fund
* Environment Rejuvenation Fund
* Pollution Solution Fund
and , above all ,
* BANMALI ( Ban Mal-Nutrition in India ) Fund
{ https://myblogepage.blogspot.in/2016/09/a-mobile-app-named-banmali.H T M L }
Some 1.2 million children ( under age of 7 ) , die in India EACH YEAR , due to mal-nutrition ( since , you do not wish to call it " Starvation " ! )
If each of these children were to be provided highly nourishing food packets each day , costing Rs 50 per day per child , that would cost the Government , Rs 2190 Crore / year
By enabling channelizing those Rs 10 lakh*crore into these Bank Accounts , we will be able to convert that Black Money into White Money ( but for use by the POOR / NEEDY of the Society )
Will those Black Money Holders come forward for such a DONATION ?
They will , if the Government promises that while depositing the old notes into these accounts ,
* NO QUESTIONS will be asked ,
* Depositor does not have to REVEAL IDENTITY !
* There will be no UPPER LIMIT
They have nothing to lose in this World and everything to gain in the NEXT !
Far better than donating crores to Religious Temples / Shrines etc !
Let those Black Money holders " donate " their hearts to the 1.2 million dying children !
I request Shri Narendrabhai Modiji to go, sit silently in front of Raj-Ghat Memorial and ask :
" Did you say : To the poor , God appears in the form of a ROTI in their hands ?
By allowing the Black Money Holders to save these children , am I going to lose face ? "
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
10 Nov 2016
www.hemenparekh.in / blogs
JAGANATHAN R ACMA, SAP(Fi-Co)
(Manager Accounts and Finance)
(915 Points)
Replied 14 November 2016
good answer