close Change the way you learn with CCI Online Coaching   view more
Home > Poll > Comments on : Is compulsory CSR for corporates a right move in new Co bill?


Please Wait ..

Sign-in to your account


Username:
Password:

Remember Me

Forgot your password?

Sign-up now



Join CAclubindia.com and Share your Knowledge. Registered members get a chance to interact at Forum, Ask Query, Comment etc.


Is compulsory CSR for corporates a right move in new Co bill?

Yes 89 %
No 9 %
Can't say 2 %
Total Votes Cast  1558
Submitted By : Admin

Read Comments


Comments on !!!

Is compulsory CSR for corporates a right move in new Co bill?



deepak

deepak

Wrote on 17 January 2013  



NARAYANAN.K.J

NARAYANAN.K.J

Wrote on 16 January 2013  

Yes



NARAYANAN.K.J

NARAYANAN.K.J

Wrote on 16 January 2013  

Yes



gaurav g. patel

gaurav g. patel

Wrote on 16 January 2013  



SIVASIVA

SIVASIVA

Wrote on 16 January 2013  

good one



Nitin Bharadwaj

Nitin Bharadwaj

Wrote on 16 January 2013  

Yes



Pooja Gandhi

Pooja Gandhi

Wrote on 16 January 2013  



CS Mehul Bhanawat CA-FINAL

CS Mehul Bhanawat CA-FINAL

Wrote on 16 January 2013  



S.ASWATH

S.ASWATH

Wrote on 16 January 2013  

Its should be make compulsory as early as possible



Ayushi

Ayushi

Wrote on 15 January 2013  



anurag srivastava

anurag srivastava

Wrote on 15 January 2013  



vanisri

vanisri

Wrote on 15 January 2013  



fatima

fatima

Wrote on 15 January 2013  



sharad

sharad

Wrote on 15 January 2013  

all corporates are under social obligation.they drive profits using the resources of society.hence csrshould be enforced.



Kawaldeep Kaur

Kawaldeep Kaur

Wrote on 15 January 2013  



nsankeerth

nsankeerth

Wrote on 14 January 2013  

yes



Mohammed Wajahat Khan

Mohammed Wajahat Khan

Wrote on 14 January 2013  

no



A.nellairaj ragupathi

A.nellairaj ragupathi

Wrote on 14 January 2013  



nitin

nitin

Wrote on 14 January 2013  

yes



RAJESH PATANGE

RAJESH PATANGE

Wrote on 12 January 2013  

yes



RAJESH PATANGE

RAJESH PATANGE

Wrote on 12 January 2013  

yes



YOGESH JHA

YOGESH JHA

Wrote on 12 January 2013  



vipulupara

vipulupara

Wrote on 12 January 2013  



Ankush Saluja

Ankush Saluja

Wrote on 12 January 2013  



Prakash Choudhary

Prakash Choudhary

Wrote on 12 January 2013  

Yes, Big corporate can do better than the government for society, that 2% will be more helpful.



lalitha

lalitha

Wrote on 12 January 2013  

Yes it is compulsary



Supriyo

Supriyo

Wrote on 12 January 2013  

yes



Varun

Varun

Wrote on 11 January 2013  

mandatory CSR results in better mgmt practices n policies... could avoid another satyam scam



Vinod U Bohra

Vinod U Bohra

Wrote on 11 January 2013  

N



shruti gupta

shruti gupta

Wrote on 11 January 2013  

YES



Nitesh

Nitesh

Wrote on 11 January 2013  



vaibhav

vaibhav

Wrote on 11 January 2013  



Tushar Verma

Tushar Verma

Wrote on 10 January 2013  

yes it will be in the interest of new generation . because the old companies act have too much clauses and sections which are beyond the practical conept.



Josmin Jose

Josmin Jose

Wrote on 10 January 2013  

yes



bhavesh goswami

bhavesh goswami

Wrote on 10 January 2013  

Yes



POOJA BHATI

POOJA BHATI

Wrote on 10 January 2013  

NOT A RIGHT MOVE....



Ankit Garg

Ankit Garg

Wrote on 10 January 2013  

.



MANOJ

MANOJ

Wrote on 10 January 2013  

YES.It is a right move.



MANOJ

MANOJ

Wrote on 10 January 2013  

YES.It is a right move.



IBRAHIM

IBRAHIM

Wrote on 09 January 2013  

yes



sravan   reddy nevuri

sravan reddy nevuri

Wrote on 09 January 2013  

compulsory



chethan

chethan

Wrote on 09 January 2013  

yes



priyamahi

priyamahi

Wrote on 09 January 2013  

Companies cannot function in an environment that is entirely different from the society. To make companies adhere to Social activities legally, CSR has to be included in Co Bill.



Madhuri Verma

Madhuri Verma

Wrote on 08 January 2013  



vicky

vicky

Wrote on 08 January 2013  



CA. Subhash Dangi

CA. Subhash Dangi

Wrote on 08 January 2013  



Manjunath Raghvendra

Manjunath Raghvendra

Wrote on 08 January 2013  



Akhil Gupta

Akhil Gupta

Wrote on 08 January 2013  



Akhil Gupta

Akhil Gupta

Wrote on 08 January 2013  



gaurav g. patel

gaurav g. patel

Wrote on 08 January 2013  



Abinash panda

Abinash panda

Wrote on 08 January 2013  

yes .........



CS CIA Shivam Thakkar

CS CIA Shivam Thakkar

Wrote on 08 January 2013  



aakash

aakash

Wrote on 07 January 2013  



BVT

BVT

Wrote on 07 January 2013  



Aashish Soni

Aashish Soni

Wrote on 07 January 2013  



andal priyadharshini

andal priyadharshini

Wrote on 07 January 2013  

yes it is needed



andal priyadharshini

andal priyadharshini

Wrote on 07 January 2013  

yes it is needed



andal priyadharshini

andal priyadharshini

Wrote on 07 January 2013  

yes it is needed



AVNISH

AVNISH

Wrote on 07 January 2013  

yes....



ankur jain

ankur jain

Wrote on 07 January 2013  

yes a good intiative.



Naveen Fathima

Naveen Fathima

Wrote on 07 January 2013  

It IS a good move!



Naveen Fathima

Naveen Fathima

Wrote on 07 January 2013  

Yes, it is mandatory for companies whose turnover exceeds 1000 crores or net worth exceeds 500 crores



dolly bhatia

dolly bhatia

Wrote on 07 January 2013  

yes



divya deepthi

divya deepthi

Wrote on 06 January 2013  

yes



D R P

D R P

Wrote on 06 January 2013  

yes



AJAY KUMAR GUPTA

AJAY KUMAR GUPTA

Wrote on 06 January 2013  



Aly Merchant

Aly Merchant

Wrote on 05 January 2013  

NOT A GOOD MOVE...CSR BECME 'COMPANY SOCIAL TAX'



Vivek Vora

Vivek Vora

Wrote on 05 January 2013  

Yes its compulsory for coroporates, earlier it was on optional basis.



javeed

javeed

Wrote on 05 January 2013  

its the right move



abhijitlodha

abhijitlodha

Wrote on 05 January 2013  

Making CSR compulsory is right step towards good corporate governance , Will bring hopes n Responsibility towards society .



Chintan

Chintan

Wrote on 05 January 2013  



javad

javad

Wrote on 04 January 2013  



Sunil Sky

Sunil Sky

Wrote on 04 January 2013  



kavyamanjarlapati

kavyamanjarlapati

Wrote on 04 January 2013  

Yes,CSR improves corporate world.....



Shashi Kumar Singh

Shashi Kumar Singh

Wrote on 04 January 2013  



CA Dhiraj Ramchandani

CA Dhiraj Ramchandani

Wrote on 04 January 2013  

Ofcoarse., its the most perfect..



VIKAS.A

VIKAS.A

Wrote on 03 January 2013  

Yes



CA.Vinita Gupta

CA.Vinita Gupta

Wrote on 03 January 2013  



CA Gaurav Verma

CA Gaurav Verma

Wrote on 03 January 2013  

Companies are earning profits from society, so they owe much to the society. Right move by govt.



andal priyadharshini

andal priyadharshini

Wrote on 03 January 2013  

Absoloutely..... A great Move in the Companies Bill....... As it will have an great impact on Society in a Positive way.............!!



andal priyadharshini

andal priyadharshini

Wrote on 03 January 2013  

Absoloutely..... A great Move in the Companies Bill....... As it will have an great impact on Society in a Positive way.............!!



andal priyadharshini

andal priyadharshini

Wrote on 03 January 2013  



zuber

zuber

Wrote on 03 January 2013  



VIKAS.A

VIKAS.A

Wrote on 03 January 2013  



mayank singhal

mayank singhal

Wrote on 03 January 2013  

Yes



Vinod

Vinod

Wrote on 03 January 2013  

corporate using society resources so in corporate turn it should be compulsory , so society have no too much damage to allow usage .



sachin

sachin

Wrote on 03 January 2013  

good belated right decision



Gaurav Aggarwal

Gaurav Aggarwal

Wrote on 03 January 2013  



vineet

vineet

Wrote on 02 January 2013  

not at all , adversely affect the corporate results in decline in GDP



vineet

vineet

Wrote on 02 January 2013  

not at all , adversely affect the corporate results in decline in GDP



vineet

vineet

Wrote on 02 January 2013  

not at all , adversely affect the corporate results in decline in GDP



vineet

vineet

Wrote on 02 January 2013  

not at all , adversely affect the corporate results in decline in GDP



Neethu Hari

Neethu Hari

Wrote on 02 January 2013  

yes, it is a right move?



BASILA V P

BASILA V P

Wrote on 02 January 2013  

yes



Karthik Venkatram

Karthik Venkatram

Wrote on 02 January 2013  



Parth

Parth

Wrote on 02 January 2013  

Corporate social responsibility is a must. That is a very good move from government.



gaurav g. patel

gaurav g. patel

Wrote on 02 January 2013  

yes



raj kumar garg

raj kumar garg

Wrote on 02 January 2013  



Sri Deepthi.S

Sri Deepthi.S

Wrote on 02 January 2013  

Yes



syam

syam

Wrote on 02 January 2013  



suraj

suraj

Wrote on 02 January 2013  

corporate social responsibility compulsion raise the company's society awareness and also make them to practice.



suraj

suraj

Wrote on 02 January 2013  

corporate social responsibility compulsion raise the company's society awareness and also make them to practice.



Sanjay Kumar Kushwaha

Sanjay Kumar Kushwaha

Wrote on 02 January 2013  

yes



jitesh

jitesh

Wrote on 02 January 2013  

yes



Srikanth

Srikanth

Wrote on 01 January 2013  

Better for the developing economy



CA Priyank Singhi

CA Priyank Singhi

Wrote on 01 January 2013  

It would enhance the social responsibilities that a corporate generally by passes. Hence it is a move in the right direction.



Shakti Arora

Shakti Arora

Wrote on 01 January 2013  



satpal

satpal

Wrote on 01 January 2013  

Its a very good move if, its implemention will be in real otherwise it will provide to the companies to increase their black money.



Hemant Kumar

Hemant Kumar

Wrote on 01 January 2013  

Yes



CS Prem Munjal

CS Prem Munjal

Wrote on 31 December 2012  

CSR means a implied contract between social and corporate. so if society confers some rights upon corporate since incorporation so there should be some responsibility upon corporates to fruit this rights



shruti chaturvedi

shruti chaturvedi

Wrote on 31 December 2012  

yes



kritika dubey

kritika dubey

Wrote on 31 December 2012  



om prakash rawat

om prakash rawat

Wrote on 31 December 2012  



Deepak Bhagtani

Deepak Bhagtani

Wrote on 31 December 2012  

Absoloutely.............. Agreat Move in the Companies Bill....... As it will have an great impact on Society in a Positive way.............!!!!!!!



Deepak Bhagtani

Deepak Bhagtani

Wrote on 31 December 2012  

Absoloutely.............. Agreat Move in the Companies Bill....... As it will have an great impact on Society in a Positive way.............!!!!!!!



Ankit Garg

Ankit Garg

Wrote on 31 December 2012  

Agreed, Compulsory CSR will inspire a company to do something towards their Corporate Social Responsibility.



arijit kundu

arijit kundu

Wrote on 31 December 2012  

nothing to say



sona

sona

Wrote on 31 December 2012  



 CA Chandrima Bhar

CA Chandrima Bhar

Wrote on 30 December 2012  



mokshita shah

mokshita shah

Wrote on 30 December 2012  

uniformity must be encouraged



ramesh kr bansal

ramesh kr bansal

Wrote on 30 December 2012  

To the some extent its works.



TusharSampatM.Com CA,CS-FINAL

TusharSampatM.Com CA,CS-FINAL

Wrote on 29 December 2012  

AGREED.



Rahul

Rahul

Wrote on 29 December 2012  



VIKAS.A

VIKAS.A

Wrote on 29 December 2012  

yes



HARI KRISHNA

HARI KRISHNA

Wrote on 29 December 2012  

CSR IS COMPULSORY FOR EVERY CORPORATE.



Rohit Kumar Singh

Rohit Kumar Singh

Wrote on 29 December 2012  



Manjunatha M K

Manjunatha M K

Wrote on 29 December 2012  



Hemanth

Hemanth

Wrote on 29 December 2012  



R.Sasi kumar

R.Sasi kumar

Wrote on 29 December 2012  

YES



Hemant Kumar

Hemant Kumar

Wrote on 29 December 2012  

Yes



satish kumar voleti

satish kumar voleti

Wrote on 28 December 2012  

Yes... When the corporates are using all the resources of the society... they have to do something to the society in turn...apart from providing the employment... they need to do some social works....



Gadi venkata narasimharao

Gadi venkata narasimharao

Wrote on 28 December 2012  



lalit kandoi

lalit kandoi

Wrote on 28 December 2012  

Yesssssssss




aman

aman

Wrote on 17 January 2013  

You need to be logged in to post comment



Submit



Quick Links







Recent Forum Messages :