Wrote on 03 November 2012
YES. CONTROL SHOULD BE WITH RBI
|
Wrote on 03 November 2012
Wrote on 03 November 2012
YES
Wrote on 03 November 2012
Of course RBI
Wrote on 03 November 2012
yes
.bmp "Rajnish Kumar Jha")
Wrote on 03 November 2012
Wrote on 03 November 2012
Wrote on 03 November 2012
Wrote on 03 November 2012
yes rbi should bank auditor appointed.
Wrote on 03 November 2012
Wrote on 03 November 2012
It will hit the true object of Audit
Wrote on 03 November 2012
Wrote on 03 November 2012
yes bank auditor appointed by RBI
Wrote on 02 November 2012
RBI have many imp work to do...
Wrote on 02 November 2012
Wrote on 02 November 2012
yes
Wrote on 02 November 2012
Wrote on 02 November 2012
Wrote on 02 November 2012
yes
Wrote on 02 November 2012
yes i think the auditor at the bank should b appointed by the RBI only..
Wrote on 02 November 2012
Wrote on 02 November 2012
YES IF RBI APPOINT THEN REDUCTION IN CURRUPTION
Wrote on 02 November 2012
Wrote on 01 November 2012
Wrote on 01 November 2012
Wrote on 01 November 2012
Wrote on 01 November 2012
Wrote on 01 November 2012
It will create independence
Wrote on 01 November 2012
yes
Wrote on 01 November 2012
yes
Wrote on 31 October 2012
Wrote on 31 October 2012
yes
Wrote on 31 October 2012
yes bank auditor should be appointed by RBI
Wrote on 31 October 2012
Yes
Wrote on 31 October 2012
Wrote on 31 October 2012
Wrote on 31 October 2012
Wrote on 31 October 2012
For better transperency in banki sector itshould be appointd by RBI.
Amit Agrwal
Wrote on 30 October 2012
Wrote on 30 October 2012
No it should not be by RBI
Wrote on 30 October 2012
Wrote on 30 October 2012
Wrote on 30 October 2012
Wrote on 30 October 2012
Wrote on 30 October 2012
for the sake of independence, Auditors shall be appinted by RBI.
Wrote on 30 October 2012
Wrote on 30 October 2012
To retain the independence
Wrote on 29 October 2012
Wrote on 29 October 2012
Wrote on 29 October 2012
Wrote on 29 October 2012
Right of appointment of a Bank Auditor for Auditor General or Controller of India
Wrote on 29 October 2012
Wrote on 29 October 2012
Wrote on 29 October 2012
Bank follows rules led by RBI so RBI Should appoint auditors to check them too...
Wrote on 28 October 2012
yes
Wrote on 28 October 2012
It will lead to quality audit.
Wrote on 28 October 2012
yes
Wrote on 28 October 2012
yes
Wrote on 27 October 2012
YES
Wrote on 27 October 2012
Yes
Wrote on 27 October 2012
Yes
Wrote on 27 October 2012
Yes
Wrote on 27 October 2012
If banks is given the power to appoints his own auditor then it will not be a public bank it will be a profit making bank
Wrote on 27 October 2012
Wrote on 26 October 2012
RBI appointment ensures independence of audit profession.
Wrote on 26 October 2012
yes
Wrote on 26 October 2012
yes RBI will be auditing by ICAI ACT
Wrote on 26 October 2012
Wrote on 26 October 2012
Wrote on 26 October 2012
yes
Wrote on 26 October 2012
Yes..
Wrote on 26 October 2012
Wrote on 26 October 2012
yes RBI appointed Bank Auditors
Wrote on 26 October 2012
yes they should be appointed by RBI
Wrote on 26 October 2012
bank auditor be appointed by RBI?
Read more at: http://www.caclubindia.com/poll/poll_update.asp#.UIpp0mffSnA
Wrote on 26 October 2012
Wrote on 26 October 2012
Wrote on 26 October 2012
yes,
Wrote on 26 October 2012
RBI appoint auditor independenty and true and fair views are give more.
Wrote on 26 October 2012
nnnnnn
Wrote on 26 October 2012
Wrote on 26 October 2012
Wrote on 26 October 2012
Yes
Wrote on 26 October 2012
Wrote on 25 October 2012
Wrote on 25 October 2012
Its better
Wrote on 25 October 2012
Wrote on 25 October 2012
yes
Wrote on 25 October 2012
yes
Wrote on 24 October 2012
Wrote on 24 October 2012
yes
Wrote on 24 October 2012
Wrote on 24 October 2012
Wrote on 23 October 2012
Wrote on 23 October 2012
For real transparency RBI should appoint Bank auditor.
Wrote on 23 October 2012
its must do that..!!!
Wrote on 23 October 2012
to provide a batter firm to batter audit
Wrote on 23 October 2012
Wrote on 23 October 2012
YEs
Wrote on 23 October 2012
Wrote on 22 October 2012
yes, being regulator of banks
Wrote on 22 October 2012
Wrote on 22 October 2012
Wrote on 22 October 2012
yes.. RBI is the regulatory authority.. so appointment of bank auditor should be done by RBI to maintain the independence of the auditors
Wrote on 22 October 2012
Wrote on 22 October 2012
Wrote on 22 October 2012
Wrote on 22 October 2012
yes
Wrote on 22 October 2012
yes
Wrote on 21 October 2012
Wrote on 21 October 2012
.jpg "CA Priya")
Wrote on 21 October 2012
Bank audit is always prone to all gifts adjustments and compromises....... So there is no second thought in this.......
Wrote on 21 October 2012
Wrote on 20 October 2012
Wrote on 20 October 2012
WHO EVER APPOINTS DOESN'T MATTER....AS TRUE AND FAIR VIEW CONCEPT IS BEST FOUND ONLY IN BOOKS.....
Wrote on 20 October 2012
Yes. Because it reduces the scope for fraud.
Wrote on 20 October 2012
YES
Wrote on 19 October 2012
yes
Wrote on 19 October 2012
Wrote on 19 October 2012
Plz provide all information you have in relation to Bank Realisation Certificate . How to maintain file in all data base while doing this work.
Wrote on 19 October 2012
Wrote on 19 October 2012
Wrote on 19 October 2012
It will improve the quelity of bank audit also
Wrote on 19 October 2012
Wrote on 19 October 2012
Yes, RBI appointed auditors shall have more scope n independence what are pre-requisites of an statutory audit.
Wrote on 19 October 2012
Yes, RBI appointed auditors shall have more scope n independence what are pre-requisites of an statutory audit.
Wrote on 19 October 2012
Wrote on 19 October 2012
Wrote on 19 October 2012
Yes,RBI appointed by Bank auditors in case of all nationalized banks
Wrote on 18 October 2012
no
Wrote on 18 October 2012
yes
Wrote on 18 October 2012
Yes....it will improve Audit Report..
Wrote on 18 October 2012
yes
Wrote on 18 October 2012
The same is possible if a prescribed threshold is discussed and laid down for effective implementation.
Wrote on 18 October 2012
Wrote on 18 October 2012
auditors can act independently
Wrote on 17 October 2012
Yes bcoz of Integrity of RBI & due 2 many other reasons..........
Wrote on 17 October 2012
yes
Wrote on 17 October 2012
Wrote on 17 October 2012
For the time being only PSU Banks' auditors are appointed by RBI.I think only RBI should appoint the auditors in case of other banks also..
Wrote on 17 October 2012
Wrote on 17 October 2012
Wrote on 17 October 2012
Wrote on 17 October 2012
ya i think so
.jpg "NITIN SHARMA")
Wrote on 17 October 2012
YES
Wrote on 16 October 2012
Yesi think it should be appointed by rbi
Wrote on 16 October 2012
Yes
Wrote on 16 October 2012
Wrote on 16 October 2012
Wrote on 16 October 2012
No
Wrote on 16 October 2012
Wrote on 16 October 2012
Never allow this. Its very odd...
Wrote on 16 October 2012
yes
Wrote on 16 October 2012
Yes for transparency it should be done by RBI.
Wrote on 16 October 2012
Wrote on 16 October 2012
To ensure independence of auditors in public sector, the procedure of appointment needs to be independent of the involvement of the management
Wrote on 15 October 2012
yes auditor for bank should be appointed by RBI by application of auditor"s
Wrote on 15 October 2012
Wrote on 15 October 2012
Wrote on 15 October 2012
yes
Wrote on 15 October 2012
This will bring in the Independence of Auditors.
Wrote on 15 October 2012
YES
Wrote on 15 October 2012
yes
Wrote on 15 October 2012
Wrote on 15 October 2012
Wrote on 15 October 2012
yes
Wrote on 15 October 2012
APPOINTMENT OF BANK AUDITOR BY THE RBI WOULD AMOUNT TO BURDENING MORE DUTIES AND RESPONSIBILITIES ON THE CENTRAL BANK GIVEN THE FACT THAT ITS ALREADY UNDER HUGE PRESSURE OF CHALKING OUT FISCAL AND MONETARY POLICIES FOR THE GOVERNMENT, ISSUE OF NOTES AND CURRENIES, REGULATING INTERNATIONAL TRADE AND ISSUE OF FOREIGN EXCHANGE. THOUGH IT CANNOT BE DENIED THAT APPOINTMENT OF BANK AUDITOR BY RBI WOULD BRING IN MORE TRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY IN THE WORKING AND DUTIES OF AUDITOR WHICH WOULD REFLECT IN THE ACCURATE AND TRUE AND FAIR VIEW OF BANKS ANNUAL REPORT AND FINACIAL RESULTS.
Wrote on 15 October 2012
APPOINTMENT OF BANK AUDITOR BY THE RBI WOULD AMOUNT TO BURDENING MORE DUTIES AND RESPONSIBILITIES ON THE CENTRAL BANK GIVEN THE FACT THAT ITS ALREADY UNDER HUGE PRESSURE OF CHALKING OUT FISCAL AND MONETARY POLICIES FOR THE GOVERNMENT, ISSUE OF NOTES AND CURRENIES, REGULATING INTERNATIONAL TRADE AND ISSUE OF FOREIGN EXCHANGE. THOUGH IT CANNOT BE DENIED THAT APPOINTMENT OF BANK AUDITOR BY RBI WOULD BRING IN MORE TRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY IN THE WORKING AND DUTIES OF AUDITOR WHICH WOULD REFLECT IN THE ACCURATE AND TRUE AND FAIR VIEW OF BANKS ANNUAL REPORT AND FINACIAL RESULTS.
Wrote on 15 October 2012
APPOINTMENT OF BANK AUDITOR BY THE RBI WOULD AMOUNT TO BURDENING MORE DUTIES AND RESPONSIBILITIES ON THE CENTRAL BANK GIVEN THE FACT THAT ITS ALREADY UNDER HUGE PRESSURE OF CHALKING OUT FISCAL AND MONETARY POLICIES FOR THE GOVERNMENT, ISSUE OF NOTES AND CURRENIES, REGULATING INTERNATIONAL TRADE AND ISSUE OF FOREIGN EXCHANGE. THOUGH IT CANNOT BE DENIED THAT APPOINTMENT OF BANK AUDITOR BY RBI WOULD BRING IN MORE TRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY IN THE WORKING AND DUTIES OF AUDITOR WHICH WOULD REFLECT IN THE ACCURATE AND TRUE AND FAIR VIEW OF BANKS ANNUAL REPORT AND FINACIAL RESULTS.
Wrote on 15 October 2012
I wont agree to it, being an auditor..
Wrote on 15 October 2012
yes
Wrote on 15 October 2012
WHO EVER APPOINTS DOESNT MATTER....AS TRUE AND FAIR VIEW CONCEPT IS BEST FOUND ONLY IN BOOKS.....
Wrote on 15 October 2012
Wrote on 15 October 2012
Wrote on 15 October 2012
yes i believe bank auditors should be appointed by RBI
Wrote on 15 October 2012
Wrote on 15 October 2012
Wrote on 14 October 2012
RBI MUST MONITOR THE PROCESS...........
Wrote on 14 October 2012
Wrote on 14 October 2012
Yes
Wrote on 14 October 2012
Yes
Wrote on 14 October 2012
income from that cud be tax free atleast
Wrote on 13 October 2012
Wrote on 13 October 2012
YA ITS RIGHT
Wrote on 13 October 2012
Wrote on 13 October 2012
100% BECAUSE THE BOSS HAVE RIGHTS TO AUDIT
Wrote on 13 October 2012
To Bring More Transparency in the Banking Sector......!!!!
Wrote on 13 October 2012
To Bring More Transparency in the Banking Sector......!!!!
Wrote on 13 October 2012
Wrote on 13 October 2012
As per banking regulation act, auditors should be appoint by RBI. Then only it will effective way of interlinking the Corporate to Auditors.
Wrote on 13 October 2012
ATLEAST THE AUDIT REPORT SHOULD TO REVIEWED BY RBI. BOTH THE BANK'S AND AUDITOR'S PERFORMANCE SHOULD BE APPRAISED. FURTHER APPOINTMENTS SHOULD BE BASED ON THE PERFORMANCE OF THE AUDITOR. A WAY TO IMPROVE THE PERFORMANCE OF BANKS AND AUDITORS.
