Avail 50% discount on All CS & CMA subjects for Dec batch . Use coupon code Dec14

×
Home > Poll > Comments on : Are you satisfied with the rail budget 2011 ?


Please Wait ..

Sign-in to your account


Username:
Password:

Remember Me

Forgot your password?

Sign-up now



Join CAclubindia.com and Share your Knowledge. Registered members get a chance to interact at Forum, Ask Query, Comment etc.


Are you satisfied with the rail budget 2011 ?

Yes 30 %
No 65 %
Can't say 4 %
Total Votes Cast  455
Submitted By : Admin

Read Comments


Comments on !!!

Are you satisfied with the rail budget 2011 ?



tarun kumar jha

tarun kumar jha

Wrote on 28 February 2011  

this is not a rail budget this is a DERAILED BUDGET



md.tahir alam

md.tahir alam

Wrote on 27 February 2011  

in present scenario it became a bad trend to give special attention to concerning state or region related to minister of railways. so i am not happy with this budget and minister too.



Santhosh Poojary

Santhosh Poojary

Wrote on 27 February 2011  

no



samdarshi

samdarshi

Wrote on 27 February 2011  

Due to not increase the fair and other charges



KARTHICK NAGARAJAN

KARTHICK NAGARAJAN

Wrote on 27 February 2011  

i am an indian not a west bengalian,



ANAND

ANAND

Wrote on 27 February 2011  

SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS



rahul pal

rahul pal

Wrote on 27 February 2011  

becoz fair of train has not increase



Robin Basak

Robin Basak

Wrote on 27 February 2011  

Srimati Mamata Banerjee making her rail budget 2011 from the point of view vote bank 2011 in W.B. only.. We have largest railways in the world in case of network & stations only but infrastructure, technology, administration are still behind than other country.. Wake Up



Rajesh Kumar Goyal

Rajesh Kumar Goyal

Wrote on 27 February 2011  

Sirf politics hai.



Rajesh Kumar Goyal

Rajesh Kumar Goyal

Wrote on 27 February 2011  

There is nothing for Punjab, Haryana, Rajyasthan etc states. She gave to their own sides only. This is very disappointment for us.



ca cs shriyans jain

ca cs shriyans jain

Wrote on 27 February 2011  

Its the worstest for the southern region. Only shown favouratism for eastern region



Hardik Dave

Hardik Dave

Wrote on 26 February 2011  

Nice budget.smile.



Chirag Goel

Chirag Goel

Wrote on 26 February 2011  

Railways have become a Political Charitable trust from which any rail minister just draws something only for his/her own state. No private partners have shown up in the last 5 years even though the hymn of PPP continued with Mamata Didi. No increase in fare rates and yet they wish to make railways profitable. Operating ratios are increasing every year since 2008. All projects to those states in which elections are to take place in near future. Further, to generate money, Railways plan to issue tax-free bonds which increases its liability by INR 20,000 Crores. Overall this rail budget is a BENGAL Budget, DESH KANGAAL Budget.



saurabh chakraborty

saurabh chakraborty

Wrote on 26 February 2011  

bcos security of pesangers,new technology in stations and good service for all age of persons are not explain



CA Shammi  Prabhakar

CA Shammi Prabhakar

Wrote on 26 February 2011  

ISKA KUCHH NAHI HO SAKTA...



Mohit

Mohit

Wrote on 26 February 2011  

i dont agree with rail budget 2011 cos my state uttar pradesh is totally ignore....



binal

binal

Wrote on 26 February 2011  

in mumbai train never on time



VIKAS GARG (V.K.G)

VIKAS GARG (V.K.G)

Wrote on 26 February 2011  

ye sarasar na insafi hai mamta jisari trains to west bengal me le gayi.......



Renu (Article)

Renu (Article)

Wrote on 26 February 2011  

Not Satisfied



Renu (Article)

Renu (Article)

Wrote on 26 February 2011  

not satisfied



CA SUNNY AGGARWAL

CA SUNNY AGGARWAL

Wrote on 26 February 2011  

COMPLETLY UNSATISFIED



Aabha jain

Aabha jain

Wrote on 26 February 2011  

not represent whole india



Saurabh Srivastava

Saurabh Srivastava

Wrote on 26 February 2011  

aise bahut saare log hai jo aaj tak shatabdi express mein sayad hi gaye honge ......AC class mein sayad hi gaye honge......kam se kam express train , passenger train to allow kar diya hota in spite of 56 shatabdi express.....!!!



kanik

kanik

Wrote on 26 February 2011  

very dissapointin budget... only politics,nd makin goals to satisfy deir own needs...



Kajal

Kajal

Wrote on 26 February 2011  

jst promises........n no reality



Muhammed Shamim Ansari

Muhammed Shamim Ansari

Wrote on 26 February 2011  

It was nothing NEW but quite satisfactory............



pawan goyal

pawan goyal

Wrote on 26 February 2011  

m nt satisfied with rail budget coz it is associated with political game dat will b played in bengal at d tym of elections



Divya Agarwal

Divya Agarwal

Wrote on 26 February 2011  

DIDI NE Bangal ko hi abad kia aur sab ko bhul gai..itni rail incidents hue he..uski bharpai kaisi hogi..??????



Paras Ruthla

Paras Ruthla

Wrote on 26 February 2011  

Rail is also for the common peoples but this rail budget is not prepared with a view to care about them.



ANIL YADAV

ANIL YADAV

Wrote on 26 February 2011  

it was not a general rail budget, rather it seemed like a state oriented (w.b.) rail budget..



charan guptha

charan guptha

Wrote on 26 February 2011  

No equal segregation of trains to all! not better budget!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!



sachin sharma

sachin sharma

Wrote on 26 February 2011  

mamta ji presents balance budget for railway



deepak

deepak

Wrote on 26 February 2011  

it looks like west bengal rail budget, not indias budget



CA Final

CA Final

Wrote on 25 February 2011  

Only for WB



Member (Account Deleted)

Member (Account Deleted)

Wrote on 25 February 2011  

this is completely a political budget



Narayana

Narayana

Wrote on 25 February 2011  

not a central Govt Budget. This is only Bengal Comming election Budget



Sharad

Sharad

Wrote on 25 February 2011  

its impartial to other states due to elections in bangal



Praveen kabra

Praveen kabra

Wrote on 25 February 2011  

yes it being average



Praveen kabra

Praveen kabra

Wrote on 25 February 2011  

yes



Satvir Singh

Satvir Singh

Wrote on 25 February 2011  

i like it bcoz of Ludhiana-New Delhi Shatabdi....tickets of earlier Shatabdis were not available for weeks



vanisri

vanisri

Wrote on 25 February 2011  

not so good



CA Chintan Vyas

CA Chintan Vyas

Wrote on 25 February 2011  

This Budget is not for whole India rather it is only for West Bengal.



charan guptha

charan guptha

Wrote on 25 February 2011  

no comments




rohit

rohit

Wrote on 28 February 2011  

hmmm

You need to be logged in to post comment





Submit



Quick Links







Recent Forum Messages :






back to the top